Following Mnet’s popular dance contest program ‘Street Woman Fighter’, ‘Street Man Fighter’ Viewers are dissatisfied with the ‘judging process’ at Judge’s judging methodIt is becoming a hot topic as it grows.
On the September 13th broadcast of ‘Smanpa’, the first elimination crew occurred as a result of a dance showdown. Judge Boa, Eunhyuk, and Wooyoung took charge of the judging, and each crew competed with K-pop songs such as BTS, Big Bang, EXO, and Seventeen.
On this day, One Million and We Dam Boys went to the EXO song battle, and Jersey Boa drew attention by saying, “It’s something I’ve already seen a lot in SM.” As a final result, One Million won with 1080 points, but after the broadcast, viewers’ complaints toward Jersey poured out.
After the broadcast, various online communities received critical responses. Viewers said, “It is a contradiction in itself that an idol evaluates a dancer”, “I don’t know who an idol who dances after being danced by a dancer evaluates”, “The public is seeing a team called One Million for the first time, so why are you talking about that?” “Aside from this, it is inconvenient to call them ‘boy’ or ‘her’ instead of the dancer’s name during the judging”, “There is a problem with fairness that idols evaluate dancers themselves” criticism, etc.
In addition, in the September 6 broadcast, the main dancer selection contest showed a scene where the judgement criteria and the result announcement did not match, leaving the fandom, and criticism of the judge is increasing.
The result was that the dancer who made a mistake in the middle of the choreography, saying that it would not be chosen, was selected as the main dancer, beating the original dancer who was selected for the choreography. “The judges who said you shouldn’t make a mistake chose the person who made a mistake as the main dancer,” he said.
The biggest criticism was that the understanding of the battle was too low. The judging criteria for battle and Correo are starkly different, but now the judges have never been able to stop a battle and have no experience in battle, so criticisms are coming out strongly.
Because of these judges’ judging standards, in battles, K-pop such as One Million’s ‘Wah’, YGX’s ‘Lupin’, and Ambitious’s ‘Next Level’ has been used to present coreo rather than battle. This is a major obstacle to show the high-level battle that viewers have been waiting for.
The controversy over the judges’ judgment has been raised since the time of ‘Street Woman Fighter’, which was broadcast before ‘Smanfar’. It became a problem for idols to rate the dance of professional dancers. The production team is proceeding with the broadcast without any feedback from viewers. In some cases, there were signs of a ‘Sman-fan’ boycott movement.
Meanwhile, Fight Jersey Boa, Eunhyuk, and Jang Wooyoung and eight teams of dancers attended the Smanpa production presentation held on August 23rd. Controversy began with the casting of Fighting Jerseys, all of whom were singers.
Regarding this, Eunhyuk said, “No matter what kind of work you do, you can’t do it only with a good response. You may be criticized or criticized. It’s a natural thing to do no matter what you do, so sitting here is more important than the burden of it. “I’m lucky,” he said calmly.
Eunhyuk, who had thought about ‘who should sit here and judge fair?’, said, “I don’t think there will be a perfectly fair judgement no matter who comes.