Planning applications for a proposed 24-hour McDonald’s outlet in Cowes on Phillip Island have triggered nearly 1,000 community objections over environmental, traffic, and health concerns.
Community Backlash and Environmental Concerns in Cowes
When Phillip Island residents began investigating the fast food application for Cowes, community opposition quickly coalesced around local groups such as Say No to McDonald’s. Member Trevor Ryan stated that community concerns range from environmental damage and health impacts to traffic and road safety issues, particularly for young children attending the primary school located just metres away from the proposed site.
Opponents argue that the global hamburger chain will damage the tourism destination’s food scene by drawing business away from local operators. Residents fighting the development fear that a wave of packaging litter will compromise Phillip Island’s unique coastal wildlife. “Rubbish does not just blow into the next suburb, it blows into our ocean,” Ryan said.
The proposed McDonald’s outlet would operate 24/7 with a maximum of 50 seats. If approved by the Bass Coast Shire, it would sit less than 20 metres from the boundary of Cowes Primary School and directly opposite retirement home units, marking the first McDonald’s franchise on Phillip Island.
Support for the Development and Competing Petitions
While the planning application has generated roughly 1,000 objections lodged with the Bass Coast Shire council, it has also received 26 letters in support.
Proponents of the development point to potential economic and convenience benefits. One supporting letter noted that a McDonald’s outlet would provide jobs for young people, alongside a place to buy coffee after 2 pm and food after 8 pm when other local businesses have closed. Another letter highlighted that the proposed site sits beside a service station, making it a suitable location that provides additional food choices for emergency services and shift workers. A 7-Eleven outlet has already been approved for that same service station site.
Despite these supportive submissions, an online petition opposing the Cowes outlet has gathered more than 5,700 signatures. Cowes health and wellness coach Victoria McGregor-Dawson argued that the location directly opposite retirement units is problematic. “You’ve got the elderly people living here, and they’re going to be infringed upon by lights, noise, smell on every level,” she said.
The Bass Coast Shire is scheduled to hold a public meeting later this month to hear further resident views on the proposal.
Broader Victorian Resistance and Impending Legislative Changes
The conflict in Cowes is part of a broader wave of resistance across Victoria, where communities from Castlemaine to Northcote are fighting fast food expansions. In the gold-rush town of Castlemaine, residents have mobilized against plans for a McDonald’s outlet to keep the town free of global fast food franchises. Mac Off Protect Castlemaine coordinator Vicki Anderson criticized upcoming regulatory changes, arguing they do not focus adequately on fast food operators setting up near schools.
Historically, local councils have held limited power to reject fast food planning applications, and decisions to refuse permits are frequently overturned by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal. A McDonald’s outlet is currently under construction in Northcote despite vehement protests from local residents.
To address these challenges, the Victorian parliament passed legislation granting councils new powers to consider health implications in planning applications—a factor councils cannot currently assess. However, these new powers do not take effect until October next year. Opponents contend that fast food operators are rushing to secure approvals before the existing rules change.
Keep reading