The African Union launched the Africa Credit Rating Agency (AfCRA) in Abuja on October 7, establishing a continent-based institution to assess sovereign and corporate borrowers.
Headquartered in Port Louis, Mauritius, the agency begins operations seven years after African heads of state endorsed the initiative in 2017. Its interim chief executive, Sifiso Falala, said AfCRA is already in discussions with 15 governments and plans initial research in Mauritius, Kenya, Togo, the Seychelles and Burundi, with the first sovereign ratings expected by the end of March.
The initiative responds to long-standing complaints that international methodologies misprice African risk. A 2023 United Nations Development Programme study estimated that subjective assumptions in sovereign ratings cost African countries $74.5 billion through higher interest payments and forgone lending, Al Jazeera reported.
Moody’s, S&P Global Ratings and Fitch Ratings reject the charge that their models systematically disadvantage African borrowers. At a Chatham House discussion in June, Moody’s sovereign risk head Marie Diron said four decades of default data show African sovereigns carry broadly the same default probability as similarly rated peers elsewhere. A B-rated issuer, she said, faces roughly a 5 percent one-year default probability regardless of region.
Falala countered that many African nations hold speculative-grade ratings despite having no history of sovereign default. “A significant number of African countries carry speculative-grade ratings despite having no history of sovereign default,” he told Al Jazeera. “This raises legitimate questions about whether prevailing models adequately capture African economic realities.”
He stressed AfCRA does not aim to manufacture higher scores. “Our objective is not to manufacture better ratings for Africa, but to produce more accurate ratings of Africa in collaboration with established rating agencies,” Falala said.
Beyond sovereign debt, AfCRA plans to rate corporations, municipalities, banks and local-currency instruments that receive limited coverage from global firms. Abdussalam Muazu, associate chartered economist at the Institute of Chartered Economists of Nigeria, said international agencies deploy few analysts on the ground and struggle to measure informal trade, mobile money networks and community finance. “African governments and companies often pay more to borrow than their ratings suggest, partly because investors know too little about them and price in the uncertainty,” Muazu told Al Jazeera.
Financial market specialist Dayo Obisan said richer domestic data and local context could expand capital access for African pension funds, banks and infrastructure projects.
“The value proposition for the creation of an Africa-focused credit rating agency centres on richer local data, contextual insight, wider coverage and support for domestic markets,” Obisan said.
AfCRA describes itself as privately owned and self-funded, with governments barred from holding shares. It will operate on a solicited basis, meaning governments pay for ratings and provide access to officials and data — a model also used by established agencies.
The African Union says safeguards against conflicts of interest will be critical to credibility.
Its defining test may come when an African government rejects an unfavourable assessment and the agency refuses to change it. “What strengthens AfCRA should ultimately strengthen the credibility of the entire credit rating industry,” Falala said. “Africa needs more credible assessments, not competing narratives.”