Bayley Returns to NXT Live Events After Decade-Long Absence
In a nostalgic return to her roots, Bayley stepped back into an NXT ring for her first house show appearance in 10 years. The event took place on Friday night, May 15, 2026, at Buffalo RiverWorks in Buffalo, New York, marking a significant milestone for the veteran superstar.
Bayley was one of three main roster stars featured on the card, appearing alongside Penta and Grayson Waller to bring veteran presence to the NXT live event.
A New Era of Competition
Ahead of the show, Bayley took to social media to express her excitement and reflection on the time elapsed since her last NXT live appearance. “10 years since I’ve done #wwenxt live events. Feeling nostalgic,” she wrote.
When asked about the excitement of returning to NXT at this stage of her career, Bayley highlighted the evolution of the brand. She noted that the primary draw is the challenge, stating, “The challenge. It’s not the NXT I once knew and these women are DIFFERENT.”
The veteran also touched upon her influence on the current generation of talent. Reflecting on how younger wrestlers are inspired by her career, Bayley shared, “It makes me believe in putting everything you have into what you feel in your heart.”
Match Highlights and Veteran Insights
Bayley secured a victory in Buffalo, teaming up with Kendal Grey and Tatum Paxley to defeat the trio of Kelani Jordan, Nikkita Lyons, and Zaria. Bayley was particularly impressed by her teammate’s skill, describing Kendal Grey as “annoying how talented she is.”
Looking back at her history with the brand, Bayley named Mercedes, Asuka, and EVA MARIE as her favorite opponents from previous NXT house shows.
Full Results: NXT Live in Buffalo, NY (May 15, 2026)
The evening featured a mix of championship defenses and high-energy matchups. Here are the complete results from the event:
- OTM defeated BirthRight
- Tristan Angels defeated Shiloh Hill
- Niko Vance defeated Tate Wilder
- Myles Borne defeated Grayson Waller to retain the WWE NXT North American title
- Bayley, Kendal Grey & Tatum Paxley defeated Kelani Jordan, Nikkita Lyons & Zaria
- Hank And Tank, Jaida Parker & Penta defeated The Vanity Project & Myka Lockwood
- Lola Vice defeated Kali Armstrong to retain the WWE NXT Women’s title
- Tony D’Angelo defeated Naraku to retain the WWE NXT title
Looking Ahead
The collaboration between the main roster and NXT continues through the weekend. Bayley, Penta, and Grayson Waller are scheduled to appear at upcoming NXT live events on Saturday, May 16, in Canton, Ohio, and Sunday, May 17, in Johnstown, Pennsylvania.
- Historic Return: Bayley competed in her first NXT house show in a decade.
- Main Roster Support: Bayley, Penta, and Grayson Waller are currently touring with NXT live events.
- Championship Stability: Myles Borne, Lola Vice, and Tony D’Angelo all successfully retained their respective titles in Buffalo.
- Future Dates: The tour continues in Canton, OH (May 16) and Johnstown, PA (May 17).