BBQ Brawl Season 4: Judges, Format, and Competition Details
The Food Network’s culinary competition BBQ Brawl returned for its fourth season, featuring a high-stakes format where professional pitmasters compete under the guidance of celebrity mentors. The season, which aired in 2023, centered on teams led by Bobby Flay, Anne Burrell, and Sunny Anderson as they vied for the title of “Master of ‘Cue.”
Who Were the Judges on BBQ Brawl Season 4?
The judging panel for the fourth season of BBQ Brawl consisted of three industry experts tasked with evaluating the contestants’ mastery of smoke, fire, and flavor. According to the official Food Network program guide, the rotating and permanent judges included:
- Carson Kressley: The television personality and designer brought an outside perspective to the tasting table.
- Adrienne Cheatham: A renowned chef and former Top Chef finalist known for her expertise in refined Southern cuisine.
- Rashad Jones: A professional pitmaster and host of Eat Street, providing technical feedback on barbecue techniques.
How Did the Competition Format Work?
The show followed a team-based format where contestants were drafted by the three mentors. Throughout the season, the teams participated in challenges designed to test their ability to manage different types of grills, smokers, and regional barbecue styles. The competition concluded when one team was eliminated, and individual chefs were eventually cut until a winner was crowned. The Warner Bros. Discovery press release confirmed that the winning chef earned the title of “Master of ‘Cue” and a feature in an issue of Food Network Magazine.

Key Differences from Previous Seasons
Season 4 placed a greater emphasis on the mentorship dynamic compared to earlier iterations of the show. While the first season focused heavily on Bobby Flay, subsequent seasons expanded the leadership roles to include other prominent Food Network stars. The inclusion of diverse guest judges—often featuring experts from the world of fashion or specific regional food cultures—served to distinguish the judging criteria from standard culinary competitions that rely solely on professional chefs.
Comparison of Competition Elements
| Feature | BBQ Brawl Season 4 |
|---|---|
| Primary Mentors | Bobby Flay, Anne Burrell, Sunny Anderson |
| Grand Prize | “Master of ‘Cue” title and Food Network Magazine feature |
| Core Judging Focus | Technique, flavor profile, and creativity |
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I watch BBQ Brawl Season 4?
Full episodes of BBQ Brawl are available to stream on Max and Discovery+, the primary streaming platforms for Food Network programming.
Is there a Season 5 of BBQ Brawl?
Yes, the Food Network continued the franchise with a fifth season, which premiered in 2024, maintaining the core competitive structure while introducing new twists to the challenges.
How are the winners determined?
Winners are determined by the judges’ blind tastings and evaluations of the final dishes presented during the season finale. The criteria include meat texture, smoke penetration, sauce balance, and the execution of side dishes.