<>
Roughly 3% of executions carried out in the United States between 1890 and 2010 were botched, according to data compiled by the Death Penalty Information Center, leaving prisoners to endure prolonged agony or delayed procedures due to protocol deviations and executioner errors.
Data From 120 Years of Capital Punishment
Between 1890 and 2010, the United States executed 8,776 people, and 276 of those executions—or 3.15%—went wrong in some capacity, according to research cited by the Death Penalty Information Center. Sarat defines a botched execution as any instance involving a violation or deviation from the protocol for a specific method, resulting in unforeseen problems or delays that caused unnecessary suffering or reflected gross incompetence by the executioner. Lethal injection accounts for the highest share of these troubled events among modern methods, according to the academic study. Out of 65 particularly prominent botched cases tracked by the Death Penalty Information Center, five occurred in recent years.
The 2018 Alabama Execution That Halted at Midnight
On February 22, 2018, Alabama scheduled the execution of Doyle Lee Hamm, who was convicted of murder committed during an armed robbery. Defense attorneys repeatedly warned that finding a viable vein to insert a catheter would be practically impossible because Hamm suffered from advanced lymphatic cancer and carcinoma. Despite those warnings, executioners spent two and a half hours attempting to set an intravenous line. As the midnight deadline approached—after which further attempts were legally prohibited—the execution was called off. Hamm ultimately died in prison from his underlying illnesses rather than by judicial execution.
Legal Shifts After Prolonged Catheter Failures in Alabama
Alabama faced similar intravenous complications on September 22, 2022, during the scheduled execution of Alan Eugene Miller, who was convicted of murdering three men during armed attacks. Executioners failed to properly set an intravenous catheter for at least 90 minutes before state officials ordered them to stop. Miller subsequently petitioned federal courts, and the state agreed never to attempt his execution via lethal injection again. On September 26, 2024, the state carried out Miller’s request to use nitrogen hypoxia, making him the second person executed in the United States through gas asphyxiation.
Months before Miller’s execution protocol changed, a similar time constraint halted the execution of Kenneth Eugene Smith on November 17, 2022. Convicted of a hire-for-murder crime, Smith faced an execution that began shortly after 10:00 p.m. but was called off at 23:21 when prison staff determined they lacked enough time to establish a second intravenous system before the midnight death warrant expired. Following that aborted attempt, Smith became the first person in the country executed via nitrogen gas on January 25, 2024.
Lethal injection and nitrogen gas cause execution failures
Which capital punishment method has the highest rate of problems?
Academic research shows that lethal injection accounts for the highest share of botched executions among modern methods, largely due to complications in establishing intravenous lines.
Who was the first person executed by nitrogen gas?
Kenneth Eugene Smith became the first person executed via nitrogen hypoxia in the United States on January 25, 2024, in Alabama, following an aborted lethal injection attempt in November 2022.
What happened to Doyle Lee Hamm after his execution was stopped?
Doyle Lee Hamm’s execution was called off on February 22, 2018, when executioners failed to find a usable vein after two and a half hours due to his advanced cancer. He remained in prison and died from his illnesses.
>
Related reading