The Shifting Legal Landscape of Online Copyright and Embedded Content
For nearly two decades, the “server test” has been a cornerstone of U.S. Copyright law, determining liability for online infringement. This principle assigns responsibility to the entity controlling the server hosting copyrighted material, rather than those simply linking to it. However, this established framework is facing increasing challenges, creating uncertainty for website operators and content creators alike. The Supreme Court’s recent decision not to review a key case leaves the future of online copyright liability in a state of flux.
What is the ‘Server Test’?
The server test dictates that direct copyright infringement liability rests with the party controlling the server where infringing content is stored, and accessible. Those who merely link or embed content are generally considered secondarily liable, potentially facing consequences only if they actively promote the infringement. This approach mirrors the analog world, where sharing information about a copyrighted work’s location doesn’t equate to direct infringement.
The Challenge to the Server Test
A growing debate centers on whether embedding content should be considered a form of “displaying” it, thereby making the embedding entity directly liable for potential copyright violations. Emmerich Newspapers is advocating for this shift, arguing that embedding constitutes a display that should trigger direct liability. If adopted, this stance could significantly increase the legal risks associated with a common internet practice.
Why Linking and Embedding Matter
Linking and embedding are fundamental to the internet’s architecture, enabling a vast range of functionalities. Millions of websites rely on these practices for tasks like font selection, music streaming, customer support, and legal compliance. Disrupting these practices could have far-reaching consequences for online activity.
The Supreme Court’s Decision
In July 2025, the Supreme Court declined to review McGucken v. Valnet, effectively leaving the Ninth Circuit’s “Server Test” as the prevailing standard for online copyright infringement involving embedded content. Nixon Peabody reports this decision maintains the existing legal framework, at least for now.
The Existing Split in Federal Courts
Despite the Ninth Circuit’s reaffirmation of the server test, a split exists among federal courts. The Western District of Texas, along with other district courts, has challenged or narrowed the application of the server test. Venable LLP notes this ongoing disagreement creates uncertainty in copyright infringement cases involving embedded images.
The Ninth Circuit’s Stance
The Ninth Circuit, in Hunley v. Instagram LLC (2023), reaffirmed that direct liability for violating the public display right requires a fixed “copy” of the work stored on a server controlled by the alleged infringer. Eric Goldman’s Blog details this ruling, highlighting the deepening divide between the Ninth Circuit and other circuits, particularly the Second Circuit, which have rejected applying the server test to embedded images.
Potential Implications of Changing the Standard
Altering the URL of embedded content could also be interpreted as a violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act’s prohibition on altering copyright management information, potentially subjecting users of link shorteners to statutory penalties – an outcome likely unintended by Congress.
Looking Ahead
The legal landscape surrounding online copyright and embedded content remains complex and evolving. While the Supreme Court’s decision provides temporary stability, the ongoing split among federal courts suggests further litigation and potential clarification are needed. The core principle of assigning primary responsibility to those with the greatest ability to prevent infringement – the server operators – remains a vital safeguard for the open and dynamic nature of the internet.
Related reading