Why Are Hibernian Fans Convinced Nick Montgomery Is Leaving the Club?

Edinburgh, UK — May 12, 2026 — Speculation surrounding the future of Hibernian FC manager Nick Montgomery has intensified among fans, with many convinced his tenure at Easter Road is nearing its end. While the club has not officially confirmed his status, recent developments—including a lack of major transfers, persistent underperformance, and mounting fan frustration—have fueled widespread belief that Montgomery’s departure is imminent. Here’s what we know, what fans are saying, and why the board’s handling of the situation has deepened the crisis.

— ### **The Case for Montgomery’s Impending Exit** Montgomery’s eight-month stint at Hibernian has been marked by inconsistency, with the club failing to replicate the defensive solidity and tactical discipline that defined his earlier career at clubs like St Mirren and Greenock Morton. While he arrived with a reputation for pragmatic, results-driven football, Hibs’ recent form—particularly in the Scottish Premiership—has left fans and pundits questioning his long-term suitability. #### **Key Triggers for Fan Backlash** 1. **Lack of Transfer Activity** – Unlike his predecessors, Montgomery has made few high-profile signings, leaving the squad largely unchanged. Fans argue this has stifled the club’s ability to compete for European spots or challenge for the title. – *Quote from a Hibs fan on Reddit (January 2026):* > *“The blame is with the board and Kensell. Montgomery wasn’t given the time to adapt his playing style or bring in his own players. You can’t make an omelette when the eggs are rotten.”* — Source 2. **Inconsistent Results** – Hibs’ recent league performances—including a string of draws and losses in the 2025-26 season—have reinforced perceptions of a team lacking direction. Montgomery’s inability to secure key wins has frustrated supporters, particularly those accustomed to the club’s historic resilience in tight matches. 3. **Board’s Handling of Managerial Turnover** – Hibernian’s history of frequent managerial changes—six managers in four years—has eroded stability. Fans point to CEO Ben Kensell’s tenure as a symbol of poor decision-making, with appointments often perceived as rushed or ill-considered. – *Criticism from Hibs supporters:* > *“Madness to sack six managers in four years. Players won’t feel settled, and without continuity, results will always suffer.”* — BBC Sport — ### **What the Club Has Said (and What It’s Avoiding)** Hibernian’s official stance remains cautious. While the club extended Montgomery’s contract in early 2025, it has not addressed rumors of a post-season exit. The silence has only amplified speculation, with fans pointing to: – **A lack of public support** from the board, despite Montgomery’s initial promise. – **No clear long-term vision** for the squad, leaving players and fans alike in limbo. – **Comparisons to recent managerial exits**, where Hibs has often waited until the last possible moment to make a change—damaging morale in the process. — ### **Fan Reactions: From Outrage to Resignation** Montgomery’s supporters acknowledge his tactical strengths but argue he was set up to fail by a board that: – **Failed to provide adequate resources** (e.g., no major signings in the January transfer window). – **Lacked faith in his philosophy** by not allowing him to rebuild the squad during the summer. – **Created an unstable environment**, with players reportedly anxious about their futures. *One fan’s perspective:* > *“Give the manager a chance to bring in his own players during the summer. The board needs to take the blame for this mess.”* — BBC Sport Meanwhile, critics of Kensell’s leadership have renewed calls for his removal, framing Montgomery’s potential exit as yet another symptom of deeper institutional problems. — ### **What Happens Next? Possible Scenarios** With the 2025-26 season nearing its conclusion, three outcomes are most likely: 1. **A Post-Season Departure** – The most probable scenario, given Hibs’ tradition of managerial changes after the campaign ends. If results do not improve, Montgomery could be sacked or offered a new role elsewhere. 2. **A Strategic Overhaul** – If Hibs finishes in a mid-table position, the board may opt for a major restructuring, including a managerial change and a clear transfer strategy for the summer. 3. **A Miracle Turnaround** – Unlikely but not impossible: A late-season surge could buy Montgomery time. However, given the current trajectory, this would require a dramatic shift in form—and fan confidence. — ### **Key Takeaways** – **Montgomery’s future is uncertain**, but the consensus among fans is that his exit is imminent. – **The board’s handling of the situation**—particularly under Kensell—has deepened distrust among supporters. – **Stability is the biggest issue**: Hibs’ revolving door of managers has hurt player morale and on-field performance. – **A clear plan is needed**: Whether Montgomery stays or goes, the club must address its structural problems to avoid repeating past mistakes. — ### **FAQ: What Fans Are Asking** Q: Will Hibernian sack Nick Montgomery before the end of the season? A: Unlikely. Clubs typically wait until the season concludes before making managerial changes, but the pressure on Montgomery is mounting. Q: Could Montgomery leave for another club? A: Possible. If Hibs does not offer him a new contract, he could pursue opportunities elsewhere, though his recent form may limit his appeal. Q: Who will replace him? A: The board has not signaled a preference, but names like Stephen Robinson or Stephen Glass have been floated in fan circles. Q: Will Ben Kensell step down if Montgomery leaves? A: Fans are demanding his resignation, but no official indication has been given. His fate may hinge on Hibs’ summer transfer strategy and league positioning. — ### **The Bigger Picture: Can Hibs Break the Cycle?** Hibernian’s managerial turmoil is not unique in Scottish football, but the frequency of changes—and the lack of long-term planning—has become a liability. For the club to escape its recent decline, it will need: ✅ **A stable managerial appointment** (preferably with a multi-year contract). ✅ **A clear transfer policy** aligned with the new manager’s philosophy. ✅ **Board accountability**, with Kensell either proving his leadership or stepping aside. Until then, the question remains: *Is Montgomery the last casualty of Hibs’ revolving door, or just another chapter in a frustrating saga?* —

Follow AchyNewsy for live updates on Hibernian’s managerial situation and transfer rumors.