Eidsivating Court of Appeal has acquitted a former childminder of causing the death of a one-year-old girl, overturning a conviction from 20 years ago.
The verdict marks the end of a two-decade legal struggle for the woman, who has maintained her innocence since the child fell into a coma while in her care in September 2006.
The child, Martine, died four days after being rushed to the hospital with severe head injuries. While the woman was originally sentenced to four years in prison for violence resulting in death—a term she has already served—the case was reopened following new medical evidence, NRK reported.
"After over 20 years, justice has finally been served," defense attorneys Thomas Randby and Victoria Westrum told NRK. They described the process as long and painful, noting that their client lived for two decades under the weight of a serious accusation that carried immense personal and social consequences.
The court’s decision to acquit was not unanimous; six of the seven members, including both professional judges and four lay judges, voted for the acquittal. The ruling concludes that it cannot be proven beyond a reasonable doubt that the injuries were inflicted while the child was in the defendant’s care.
Challenging the medical evidence
The acquittal hinged on a reassessment of medical testimony that differed significantly from the conclusions reached in the 2019 Borgarting Court of Appeal trial. Defense lawyers argued that the Eidsivating court conducted a more thorough review of the medical facts, ultimately determining that the injuries could have occurred days before the child arrived at the dayminder’s home.

The court did not rule out that the injuries could have been the result of an accident, such as a fall. Evidence presented during the trial included testimony that the child had fallen from her grandparents’ bed earlier that weekend, TV 2 reported.
A long path to exoneration
The case has seen several turns since the initial charges. Following a 2009 police decision to drop the case due to lack of evidence, it was reopened in 2016, just before the statute of limitations would have expired. While a district court acquitted the woman in 2018, the Borgarting Court of Appeal later convicted her in 2019.
The Criminal Cases Review Commission eventually granted a new trial in September 2023, citing new medical assessments that suggested a reasonable possibility of acquittal had the evidence been known during the 2019 proceedings.
Remaining legal steps
The prosecution has not yet decided whether to accept the verdict or appeal the case. Prosecutors Christer Gangsø and Ellisiv Emblem Bentdal said that they will review the judgment carefully before sending their recommendation to the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, which holds the authority to decide on a potential appeal.
If the acquittal stands, the woman may be eligible to file a claim for compensation for the time she spent serving the four-year prison sentence.
Spørsmål om gjenåpningen av saken
Why was the case reopened after 20 years?
The Gjenopptakelseskommisjonen (Criminal Cases Review Commission) decided to reopen the case in September 2023 based on new medical expert assessments. The commission concluded there was a reasonable possibility the defendant would have been acquitted if this evidence had been available during the previous trial.
What was the central point of contention in court?
The primary question was the timing of the head injuries. The defense presented evidence from experts, such as professor John-Bjarne Hansen, suggesting the injuries could have occurred up to 48 hours before the child fell into a coma, contradicting the theory that the harm was caused during the child’s stay on September 4, 2006.
Is the acquittal final?
No, the verdict is not yet legally enforceable. The prosecution is currently reviewing the judgment and will submit a recommendation to the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions to determine if the ruling should be accepted or appealed.