The digital economy’s rapid expansion has prompted increased scrutiny from antitrust regulators worldwide. A key focus of this oversight is the rise of powerful digital ecosystems – interconnected platforms offering diverse services – adn the potential for these ecosystems to stifle competition.In Germany, the Federal Cartel Office (BKartA) has been at the forefront of addressing these concerns, especially through the enforcement of Section 19a of the German Competition Act (GWB).
Digital ecosystems and Gatekeeper Power
Table of Contents
Digital ecosystems are characterized by a wide range of interconnected products and services designed to meet a notable portion of consumer needs. Companies operating these ecosystems, such as Google, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and Microsoft, benefit from economies of scope, perhaps establishing themselves as “rule setters” within their respective markets [[2]]. This dominant position can create considerable barriers to entry for competitors and lead to “lock-in” effects, making it challenging for consumers and businesses to switch to choice platforms.
Enforcement Under Section 19a GWB
Introduced in 2021, Section 19a GWB specifically targets large digital companies with “outstanding cross-market importance for competition.” This provision empowers the BKartA to address anticompetitive practices before they become firmly entrenched. The focus is on ensuring competitors have access to essential markets, particularly in procurement, sales, and interoperability [[1]].
Recent Cases and Actions
The BKartA has already taken action against Google in several cases. A notable example, expected to be completed in 2025, involves google’s requirement that car manufacturers license its Automotive Services (navigation, app store, voice assistance) as a package. The BKartA deemed this practice anticompetitive and intervened, along with restrictive licensing conditions related to Google Maps content.
Ongoing investigations include scrutiny of algorithmic pricing practices on Amazon Marketplace and apple’s tracking regulations for third-party apps. the BKartA is investigating whether Apple unfairly advantages itself in advertising through its control over tracking, attribution, and fraud prevention.
Private Enforcement of Antitrust claims
Section 19a GWB also facilitates private enforcement of antitrust claims. Once the BKartA issues a legally binding prohibition order, competitors and other market participants can independently pursue legal action. Furthermore, organizations like the Competition Center eV can enforce antitrust claims on behalf of their members, providing a mechanism for companies to challenge anticompetitive behavior [[1]].
Looking Ahead
The german approach to regulating digital ecosystems, particularly through Section 19a GWB, serves as a model for other jurisdictions grappling with the challenges posed by dominant digital platforms. As the digital economy continues to evolve, ongoing vigilance and proactive enforcement will be crucial to fostering competition and protecting consumer interests. The increasing complexity of digital markets requires regulators to adapt and refine their approaches to ensure a level playing field for all market participants [[3]].
Contact Details
Jennifer Müller, LL.M.
consultant for competition law
Competition Center eV
Tannenwaldallee 6
61348 Bad Homburg
Telephone: +49 6172 121532