A 58-year-old migrant dairy worker from Kenya has lost his final legal bid to secure permanent residence in New Zealand after failing to disclose a pending murder charge to immigration authorities, RNZ reported. The worker, who spent roughly 12 years milking cows across New Zealand farms since arriving in 2007, now faces permanent exclusion after the Immigration and Protection Tribunal upheld a decision by Immigration New Zealand to reject his visa application.
Visa application interrupted by family tragedy and murder charges
The legal battle centers on a short-lived 2022 residence visa category designed for applicants with skilled or scarce jobs. The dairy worker applied under this pathway alongside his wife and two children, who remained in Kenya. While Immigration New Zealand processed his paperwork, a family tragedy interrupted his plans. In January 2023, the man flew back to Kenya following his mother’s death, The Gist reported. Eleven days later, a second relative died amid an escalating family dispute, prompting local police to charge the man and one of his brothers with murder.
Three months passed before the Kenyan High Commission notified New Zealand officials about the criminal case and the court-ordered travel ban preventing the man from leaving the country. Immigration New Zealand ruled that the applicant’s failure to proactively disclose the charge was deliberate, serving as sufficient grounds to deny the residence visa. The tribunal subsequently affirmed that ruling, noting that immigration officials were under no obligation to indefinitely defer applications while awaiting foreign trial outcomes that faced repeated scheduling delays.
Tribunal Dismisses Family Hardship Claims
The applicant challenged the rejection by arguing that the tribunal and Immigration New Zealand wrongly inferred his guilt from an unadjudicated charge. He submitted multiple character references from former New Zealand employers who described him as a trusted herd manager—with one farm owner calling him nearly a family member—and his legal counsel insisted the evidence against him was weak. He also pointed to severe mental health struggles affecting both himself and his child following the January 2023 bereavement, alongside alleged police corruption in Kenya that complicated his legal defense.
Beyond the criminal proceedings, the dairy worker emphasized the humanitarian toll on his family in Kenya. Without his New Zealand income, his wife and children faced severe financial distress. His older child risked forfeiting her university degree, and his younger child missed classes after school fees fell into arrears. Despite these appeals, the tribunal found that no special circumstances warranted intervention from the immigration minister, cementing the refusal of his residency application.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the timeline of the worker’s time in New Zealand?
The 58-year-old first arrived in New Zealand in 2007, working as an assistant herd manager until 2016. He returned to the dairy industry in 2019 as a herd manager, accumulating roughly 12 years of total work experience in the country over a 19-year span, according to The Gist.
Has the murder trial in Kenya taken place?
No, the trial has not yet taken place. Court proceedings faced multiple delays, initially because the man’s co-accused absconded and authorities had to wait for his subsequent arrest, RNZ reported.
Did Immigration New Zealand wait for any updates before declining the visa?
Yes, Immigration New Zealand deferred its final decision three times to accommodate the pending trial in Kenya, though the applicant argued the extensions were insufficient, including one deferral lasting just 36 days.
Related reading