Matt Holliday Slashes Price on Stillwater Estate With Professional Baseball Field
Former MLB All-Star Matt Holliday listed his sprawling Stillwater, Oklahoma, estate for $8.95 million, down significantly from its original $12 million asking price set in February. The price cut coincides with a major reduction in acreage included in the primary sale, shrinking the offering from 136 acres down to 20 acres.
The property, built in 2022 behind private gates, spans 7,500 square feet and includes five bedrooms, two home offices, and a powder room featuring Gucci wallpaper. It once held the title of the most expensive single-family home for sale in Oklahoma. That distinction now belongs to a contemporary mansion in Oklahoma City listed at $9.6 million, excluding large ranch properties with eight-figure price tags. Wyatt Poindexter of The Agency serves as the listing agent for the Stillwater property.
Price cut limits base sale to 20 acres
The decision to cut the price by more than $3 million directly altered what buyers receive for the base figure. While the initial February listing packaged the home with all 136 surrounding acres, the updated $8.95 million price tag applies strictly to the 20-acre parcel surrounding the main residence. Prospective buyers retain the option to purchase the remaining acreage separately, according to listing details provided by Poindexter.
Holliday purchased the Stillwater land for $3 million in 2018, the same year he officially retired from Major League Baseball, according to PropertyShark records. The former outfielder grew up in Stillwater and designed the expansive estate to accommodate large gatherings. Earlier this year, Holliday told Mansion Global that hosting college students and professional athletes for meals and conversation ranked among his favorite uses for the property.
Professional baseball field supports family athletic training
The defining feature of the estate remains its professionally lit baseball field, complete with professional turf, bleachers, a fire pit behind home plate, and dedicated batting cages. Poindexter noted that the setup was built for athletic performance rather than mere aesthetics. Holliday utilized the diamond both recreationally and to train his sons.
The family’s baseball legacy heavily influenced the property’s design. Oldest son Jackson plays for the Baltimore Orioles, while second-oldest son Ethan was selected fourth overall by the Colorado Rockies in last year’s MLB draft.
Beyond the diamond, the estate features a wide array of athletic and recreational amenities. An indoor building houses a basketball and pickleball court alongside the batting cages. Additional features include a putting green, a home gym, running trails, a two-level pool with a waterfall, a hot tub, an outdoor kitchen, a guest house, and a workshop.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Holliday Estate
Can the remaining acreage be purchased with the house?
Yes, the remaining acreage can be purchased separately from the 20-acre parcel currently offered with the $8.95 million home, according to listing agent Wyatt Poindexter of The Agency.
What are the primary sports amenities on the property?
The estate features a professionally lit baseball field with turf and bleachers, batting cages, an indoor pickleball and basketball court, a putting green, a gym, and running trails.
Who holds the listing for the Stillwater property?
Wyatt Poindexter of The Agency represents the listing.