Max Scherzer Returns to Blue Jays: What’s Next for MLB Pitching Market?

The Toronto Blue Jays have brought back veteran pitcher Max Scherzer on a one-year, $3 million deal with potential performance bonuses up to $10 million, bolstering their starting rotation as they aim for another deep playoff run. This move leaves fewer impactful starting pitching options available for other teams in need.

Scherzer’s Reunion with Toronto

Max Scherzer, nicknamed “Mad Max,” returns to the Blue Jays after a previous stint with the team. The 41-year-vintage pitcher appeared in 17 games and logged 85 innings last season, including three playoff starts. He expressed a desire to continue playing after the 2023 World Series, stating, “There’s no way that was my last pitch.” Sportsnet reports that Scherzer was valued for his on-field performance and his leadership in the clubhouse, contributing to team dynamics and strategy.

Remaining Starting Pitching Options

With Scherzer off the market, the pool of available starting pitchers has significantly diminished. The remaining options are largely considered mid-to-lower tier, including Zack Littell, Patrick Corbin, Nestor Cortes, Jon Gray, and Marcus Stroman. However, Lucas Giolito stands out as the most attractive remaining free agent.

Lucas Giolito: The Top Remaining Pitcher

Right-hander Lucas Giolito, who had a successful 2025 season with the Boston Red Sox, is now the best starting pitcher available in free agency. He went 10-4 with a 3.41 ERA in 26 starts last year. MLB.com

Potential Landing Spots for Giolito

Two teams have emerged as potential fits for Giolito: the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Atlanta Braves. The Diamondbacks are facing pitching shortages due to injuries to Corbin Burnes (Tommy John surgery) and Merrill Kelly (intercostal nerve irritation). Atlanta is dealing with injuries to Hurston Waldrep and Spencer Schwellenbach, creating a need for starting pitching depth.

Trade Market as an Alternative

Teams seeking starting pitching may likewise explore the trade market. However, for teams looking to add a free agent starter, Giolito represents the most viable option at this point.

Looking Ahead

Max Scherzer’s return to the Blue Jays strengthens their chances of contending for a World Series title. As the free agency market continues to evolve, Lucas Giolito is poised to be a highly sought-after commodity, and teams with pitching needs will likely intensify their pursuit. The pitching market remains fluid, and further developments are expected as teams address their needs before the start of the season.

Max Scherzer’s Wikipedia page provides a comprehensive overview of his career.