Maya Rudolph Makes Broadway Debut in ‘Oh, Mary!’ as Mary Todd Lincoln

Emmy Award-winning actress and Saturday Night Live alum Maya Rudolph takes center stage in her highly anticipated Broadway debut, starring in Oh, Mary!, a dark comedy by Tony Award-winning playwright Cole Escola. The production, which opened on April 28, 2026, at the historic Lyceum Theatre, reimagines the final weeks of Mary Todd Lincoln’s life through a bold, absurdist lens.

The Premise: A Demented Take on History

Oh, Mary! offers a satirical and irreverent portrayal of Mary Todd Lincoln, the often-misunderstood wife of President Abraham Lincoln, in the days leading up to his assassination. Written by Cole Escola, the play blends historical fiction with modern comedy, depicting Mary as a cabaret-obsessed, alcoholic figure navigating her tumultuous marriage and the political chaos of the era. The production is directed by Tony Award winner Sam Pinkleton, whose dynamic staging has been praised for its inventive approach to storytelling.

The play first premiered Off-Broadway at the Lucille Lortel Theatre in 2024, where it quickly gained a cult following and extended its run three times due to overwhelming demand. Its transition to Broadway last summer was met with critical acclaim, breaking box-office records at the Lyceum Theatre—including becoming the first show in the theater’s 121-year history to gross over $1 million in a single week. The production earned two Tony Awards in 2025: one for Lead Actor in a Play for Escola (who originated the role of Mary Todd Lincoln) and another for Pinkleton’s direction.

Maya Rudolph Leads an All-Star Cast

Rudolph, known for her iconic roles in SNL, Bridesmaids, Loot and Big Mouth, steps into the role of Mary Todd Lincoln for an eight-week limited engagement, running through June 20, 2026. Her casting has been a major draw for audiences, marking her first foray onto the Broadway stage. In a recent interview with Broadway.com, Rudolph expressed her excitement about the role, calling it “a dream come true” and praising Escola’s unique vision for the character.

Joining Rudolph on stage are several returning cast members from the original production, including:

• Phillip James Brannon as Mary’s Husband (Abraham Lincoln), reprising his role after originating it Off-Broadway.
• Cheyenne Jackson as Mary’s Teacher, returning to the production after a limited run opposite Jane Krakowski and John-Andrew Morrison earlier this season.
• Bianca Leigh as Mary’s Chaperone, who originated the role both Off-Broadway and on Broadway.
• Tony Macht as Mary’s Husband’s Assistant, continuing his performance with the company.

The ensemble is rounded out by Hannah Solow, Martin Landry, and Julian Manjerico, who bring additional depth and energy to the production.

The Creative Team Behind the Comedy

Oh, Mary! is the brainchild of Cole Escola, a multifaceted talent known for their work as an actor, writer, and comedian. Escola’s previous credits include the television series Jeffery & Cole Casserole, Difficult People, At Home with Amy Sedaris, Search Party, and Big Mouth. Their stage work, including Help! I’m Stuck! and The First Gay President, has been celebrated for its sharp wit and fearless approach to comedy.

Director Sam Pinkleton, a Tony Award winner for his work on Oh, Mary!, is known for his innovative and visually striking staging. His collaboration with Escola has been instrumental in bringing the play’s unique blend of humor and pathos to life.

A Record-Breaking Production

Since its Broadway debut, Oh, Mary! has captivated audiences and critics alike, earning a reputation as one of the most original and entertaining shows on the Great White Way. The production’s success is a testament to its bold storytelling, stellar performances, and the creative vision of its team. Its record-breaking box-office numbers reflect the high demand for fresh, unconventional theater that challenges traditional narratives.

The play’s ability to balance humor with historical themes has resonated with audiences, offering a fresh perspective on a well-known figure. As Playbill noted in its coverage of the production, Oh, Mary! “redefines what it means to bring history to life on stage, blending absurdity with genuine emotional depth.”

What to Expect: A Night of Laughter and Satire

Audiences attending Oh, Mary! can expect a night of raucous comedy, sharp satire, and unexpected emotional moments. The play’s unique take on Mary Todd Lincoln’s life—described in press notes as “through the lens of an idiot”—offers a fresh and irreverent look at history, blending fact with fiction in a way that is both hilarious and thought-provoking.

The production’s limited run through June 20 means tickets are in high demand. For those eager to experience Rudolph’s Broadway debut or revisit the show’s unique brand of comedy, securing seats early is highly recommended.

Key Takeaways

• Maya Rudolph’s Broadway Debut: The Emmy-winning actress stars as Mary Todd Lincoln in Oh, Mary!, marking her first appearance on Broadway.
• Limited Engagement: Rudolph’s run is set for eight weeks, concluding on June 20, 2026.
• Record-Breaking Success: The production has shattered box-office records at the Lyceum Theatre, including a historic $1 million week.
• Tony Award-Winning Team: The play is written by Cole Escola and directed by Sam Pinkleton, both of whom won Tony Awards for their work on the production.
• All-Star Cast: Rudolph is joined by Phillip James Brannon, Cheyenne Jackson, Bianca Leigh, and Tony Macht, among others.
• Unique Premise: The play offers a satirical and absurdist take on Mary Todd Lincoln’s life in the weeks leading up to Abraham Lincoln’s assassination.

FAQ

Who wrote Oh, Mary!?

Oh, Mary! is written by Cole Escola, a Tony Award-winning playwright, actor, and comedian known for their work in television and theater.

Where is Oh, Mary! playing?

The production is running at the Lyceum Theatre on Broadway, located at 149 W 45th St, Modern York, NY 10036.

How long is Maya Rudolph’s run in Oh, Mary!?

Maya Rudolph’s limited engagement began on April 28, 2026, and will conclude on June 20, 2026.

Has Oh, Mary! won any awards?

Yes, the production won two Tony Awards in 2025: Lead Actor in a Play for Cole Escola and Director of a Play for Sam Pinkleton.

What is the play about?

Oh, Mary! is a dark comedy that reimagines the final weeks of Mary Todd Lincoln’s life, portraying her as a cabaret-obsessed alcoholic navigating her tumultuous marriage and the political upheaval of the era.

Final Thoughts

Maya Rudolph’s Broadway debut in Oh, Mary! is a must-see event for theater enthusiasts and comedy fans alike. With its sharp writing, stellar cast, and record-breaking success, the production offers a fresh and entertaining take on history that is not to be missed. Whether you’re a longtime fan of Rudolph’s work or simply looking for a night of laughter and satire, Oh, Mary! delivers an unforgettable experience.