A midwife facing a two-year temporary exclusion from the Simone Veil maternity hospital in Vitré, France, took her case to the Conseil d’État in Paris on October 22, 2026, after lower administrative courts upheld the disciplinary measure, ouest-france.fr reported. The hospital director originally handed down the suspension on June 19, 2026, citing a breakdown in trust that hindered the smooth running of the service and compromised patient care.
The practitioner initially challenged the decision before the judge of the administrative court of Rennes, which rejected her request in an order issued on August 6, 2026. Seeking emergency relief once more, she appeared before France’s highest administrative court to argue that her lengthy absence and eventual return would cause operational difficulties for both her department and her patients. The reporting magistrate reviewed multiple professional incidents involving the midwife, noting a persistent lack of dialogue with physicians and a recurring refusal to follow medical directives.
Disputed Medical Protocols Fuel the Hospital Disciplinary Action
The case before the Conseil d’État centers on specific clinical disagreements between the suspended midwife and attending physicians at the Ille-et-Vilaine medical facility. According to the reporting magistrate, the practitioner refused to administer oxytocin—a hormone used to accelerate contractions during labor—to a laboring patient despite a direct order from the obstetrician. In a separate incident, she sent a patient home after a doctor explicitly requested that the individual remain hospitalized.
While the magistrate acknowledged that the division of responsibilities between midwives and doctors involves fine professional lines, he maintained that the accumulated incidents reflected a severe breakdown in clinical collaboration. The gravity of these shortcomings justifies the gravity of the sanction,
the magistrate stated during the proceedings, advising the court to dismiss the appeal.
What Happens Next in the Legal Proceedings
The Conseil d’État is scheduled to deliver its final decision regarding the midwife’s suspension in the coming weeks. The ruling will determine whether the two-year exclusion from the Vitré health facility remains in effect or if the matter requires further legal review.
Related reading