International Edition
Latest News
Health

MPs Vote 225-89 to Advance MAID Bill C-41 to Committee

Conservative MPs are pushing the federal government to divide its medical assistance in dying legislation to permit separate votes on mental illness provisions and degenerative diseases. Members of Parliament voted 225 to 89 on November 17 to send…

MPs Vote 225-89 to Advance MAID Bill C-41 to Committee

Conservative MPs are pushing the federal government to divide its medical assistance in dying legislation to permit separate votes on mental illness provisions and degenerative diseases.

Members of Parliament voted 225 to 89 on November 17 to send Bill C-41 to the House of Commons Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights for study. Nearly 40 Conservative MPs voted in favor of the bill despite expressing concerns about its contents.

The Liberal government moved to limit debate on the legislation on Monday. MPs adopted a motion introduced by Justice Minister Sean Fraser to restrict second reading debate to one additional day, drawing opposition criticism over truncated timelines for a sensitive subject.

Assisted Dying Bill: Watch the moment MPs voted in favour of the bill

The legislation requires approval from both the House of Commons and the Senate before March 17, 2027, the deadline when current law would automatically extend medical assistance in dying access to individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness.

Debate and Committee Review of Bill C-41

Bill C-41 amends the Criminal Code to establish a framework for advance requests while simultaneously blocking the scheduled expansion of assisted-dying eligibility for mental illness. Under current Canadian law, eligibility is restricted to adults at least 18 years old with a serious and incurable physical illness, disease, or disability in an advanced state of irreversible decline who can provide informed consent at the time of the procedure.

MPs Vote 225-89 to Advance MAID Bill C-41 to Committee
Photo: Horizon Weekly

The proposed advance request system would apply to individuals suffering from degenerative conditions such as dementia or ALS, enabling them to request an assisted death before losing cognitive capacity. Provincial governments would decide whether to implement these requests through their respective health systems.

Liberal MP Marcus Powlowski, who chaired the parliamentary committee on medical assistance in dying, said that separating the votes on mental illness and advance requests would have been preferable because Conservative parliamentarians might support one measure while opposing the other.

“Conservatives are split on the issue,” Powlowski said. “I think people may have had conflicting views on those two issues.”

MPs debate assisted dying bill in fresh Commons vote

Conservatives Support Blocking Mental Illness MAID Expansion

Conservative MPs have stated their support for blocking access to assisted dying for individuals suffering solely from a mental illness, but they want the legislation split to allow deeper scrutiny of advance requests. Conservative MP Ben Lobb said he voted for the bill but desires greater clarity regarding advance requests and safety protections for psychiatric patients.

Conservative MP Corey Tochor criticized the broader trajectory of the program, telling CTV News that halting the mental illness expansion is necessary for society.

MPs Vote 225-89 to Advance MAID Bill C-41 to Committee
Photo: meadowlakeNOW

“The expansion of MAID is wrong for our society, and it’s a nuanced position that every Canadian is very sensitive to,” Tochor said, according to CTV News. “I just believe it’s horrendous what we’re doing with MAID in Canada today.”

The federal government stated in a media release that any advance request must remain voluntary, free from external pressure, and governed by rigorous safeguards. The legislation requires two independent medical practitioners or nurse practitioners to confirm that an advance request meets statutory requirements, and prohibits the procedure if an individual demonstrates resistance.

Born in Antigonish and raised in Merigomish, Nova Scotia, Sean Fraser was elected as the member of Parliament for Central Nova in 2015. Before entering politics, he worked as a lawyer in Calgary and completed a master’s degree in public international law from Leiden University in the Netherlands.

The Bloc Québécois also registered objections regarding the restricted debate timeline. The bill proceeds through the parliamentary committee stage ahead of the March deadline.

About the author: Health Desk

Health Desk at Archynewsy.