International Edition
Latest News
Business

Napa Planning Commission Recommends Bans on New Drive-Thrus, New Fossil-Fuel Gas Stations

"We lived on drive-thru services for a while, and pull-up services," Commissioner Alex Myers told The Press Democrat. The Napa Planning Commission voted 4-1 Thursday to recommend banning new and expanded drive-thrus and voted unanimously to prohibit new…

Napa Planning Commission Recommends Bans on New Drive-Thrus, New Fossil-Fuel Gas Stations

“We lived on drive-thru services for a while, and pull-up services,” Commissioner Alex Myers told The Press Democrat.

The Napa Planning Commission voted 4-1 Thursday to recommend banning new and expanded drive-thrus and voted unanimously to prohibit new fossil-fuel gas stations, sending the zoning ordinance update to the City Council for final adoption. The recommendations cap a multi-year effort to align land-use rules with the city’s climate goals.

Commissioners endorsed the changes during a Nov. 19 hearing on the city’s ongoing zoning update. Planning manager Ryder Dilley said the bans would not affect existing facilities, though current drive-thrus could be improved but not expanded.

Drive-thru ban splits commission

Myers cast the lone dissenting vote on the drive-thru prohibition. He said research does not show a substantial emissions reduction from banning drive-thrus and argued the service provides essential access for families with young children.

Isometric editorial illustration of a bare fuel island in a flat concrete forecourt beside a plain curb cut and lane stripe
Photo: wisevoter.com

“When I had three children in car seats in the car, I couldn’t take them into a place but also couldn’t leave them in a car,” Myers said.

Commissioner Eryn Ebach supported the ban, saying automobile-focused land uses undermine community connection.

Napa Planning Commission looks to ban new drive-thrus — KPIX | CBS NEWS BAY AREA

“I have a strong opinion in terms of whether or not they are the highest and best use of land in most cases, and my argument is that they are not,” Ebach told The Press Democrat.

Chairperson Lindsay Owen agreed, noting that curb-side pickup now offers an alternative.

“If you do have three toddlers in car seats they will bring your food out to you now,” Owen said. Commissioner Lisa Massaro added that Napa already has plenty of drive-thrus, which will remain.

Gas station ban extends countywide restriction

The fossil-fuel gas station ban drew no opposition. New fossil-fuel stations have been effectively banned throughout the rest of Napa County, and the city’s move would extend that restriction within municipal limits. Napa had enforced a two-year interim ordinance blocking new gas stations, but that measure expired in April 2025 before a permanent update was drafted, according to The Press Democrat.

2021 Raising Cane’s denial sparked debate

The drive-thru prohibition traces back to 2021, when the City Council denied a drive-thru for a Raising Cane’s restaurant proposed at the Soscol Square center on Soscol Avenue. Members of the local environmental group Napa Climate NOW! pushed for the ban to combat climate change. The council approved the project without the drive-thru, but the development never broke ground, The Press Democrat reported.

The City Council will consider the zoning ordinance update at a future meeting. A date has not been set. Residents can track the council agenda for the item and offer public comment before a final vote.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.