International Edition
Latest News
News

Pa. Board of Education Rejects Test Scoring Changes, Delaying Results for 900,000 Students

“We will just have to go back, we’ll have to make sure that we run them under the old (scoring system),” said Amy Lena, Department of Education Deputy Secretary, reported Chalkbeat. The Pennsylvania State Board of Education rejected…

Pa. Board of Education Rejects Test Scoring Changes, Delaying Results for 900,000 Students

“We will just have to go back, we’ll have to make sure that we run them under the old (scoring system),” said Amy Lena, Department of Education Deputy Secretary, reported Chalkbeat.

The Pennsylvania State Board of Education rejected a state Department of Education proposal on Thursday that would have altered scoring thresholds for standardized tests taken by roughly 900,000 students statewide. The 5-9 vote against the plan, with one abstention, means state officials must recalculate spring results for the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment and high school Keystone exams using previous benchmarks, extending a wait for districts and families.

State officials introduced the plan two weeks prior to the vote, arguing that updating the thresholds would improve scoring accuracy and increase the share of students categorized as advanced. Opponents on the board argued the timeline was flawed, citing technical glitches during the spring administration when online testing was mandatory for all districts.

Board Members Cite Process Concerns

Board members pointed to communication breakdowns and a rushed rollout as reasons for their opposition. State Sen. Lindsey Williams, the minority chair of the Senate Education Committee, voted against the measure and criticized the lack of advance notice from education officials.

“I’m not convinced that 2026, the year when nearly half the students took the test online for the first time and there were tech issues in its administration … is the right year to serve as our baseline going forward,” Williams told Penn Capital-Star.

House Education Committee Chair Peter Schweyer was the sole legislator on the board to vote for the proposal. While acknowledging the timing was difficult, Schweyer defended the update by noting that math and reading cut scores had remained unchanged since 2015. Mark Gleason, managing partner of The Drexel Fund, told The Philadelphia Inquirer that pursuing changes without sufficient parent input risked lowering academic standards.

Philadelphia School Selection Delays

The rejection of the scoring changes creates additional uncertainty for the Philadelphia school district, which has twice postponed its school selection window while awaiting official state test results. Students must meet specific PSSA score thresholds to qualify for admission to competitive magnet schools through the application process.

District officials previously announced plans to temporarily close the school selection website from Nov. 24 to Dec. 2 to upload student test score data, with the application period scheduled to close Dec. 16. A district spokesperson did not respond to requests for comment regarding whether official scores will be available by the December deadline.

Pa. Board of Education Rejects Test Scoring Changes, Delaying Results for 900,000 Students
Photo: inquirer.com

“The whole purpose of having these assessments is to inform instruction for the coming year, and right now we're almost halfway through the current year” said board Vice Chair Carol Aichele.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the Department of Education propose changing the cut scores?

“to ensure that performance labels accurately reflect what students know and can do, but not to make assessments easier or harder” said Amy Lena, a PDE Deputy Secretary. Math and reading cut scores were last updated in 2015, while Keystone cut scores were last revised in 2012, according to reporting by The Philadelphia Inquirer.

Philly school students
Photo: penncapital-star.com

How many students participated in the spring assessments?

Roughly 900,000 students statewide took the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment and high school Keystone exams in the spring, according to data provided to Chalkbeat.

The Pennsylvania State Board of Education, created by the General Assembly in 1963 and reestablished in 1988, comprises 21 members who also serve as the State Board of Career and Technical Education. Seventeen members are appointed by the Governor with Senate consent for overlapping six-year terms, while four legislative members hold seats by virtue of their leadership positions on the House and Senate Education Committees.

What is the status of Philadelphia school applications?

The application period for Philadelphia’s selective admissions schools remains scheduled to close on Dec. 16, following two prior delays by the district while awaiting official state test scores, as detailed by The Philadelphia Inquirer.

About the author: Newsroom

Newsroom at Archynewsy.