Researchers are proposing to replace the Body Mass Index (BMI) with a diagnostic framework that combines general health indicators and direct body-fat measurements, a change that would reclassify millions of people worldwide, according to a study published in Nature.
The proposal, led by Professor Francesco Rubino of King’s College London, argues that the diagnosis of obesity should not automatically equate to poor health. Under the new system, obesity would be split into two distinct categories: preclinical obesity, viewed as a risk factor rather than an active disease, and clinical obesity, referring to cases where the condition causes actual medical complications.
Data gathered from nearly 850,000 adults in Spain, the United Kingdom, China and the United States show that only about 25 percent to 33 percent of those currently labelled as obese actually have diminished health. The researchers estimate that while 1 percent to 3 percent of people currently classified as obese via BMI would no longer meet the definition, an additional 5 percent to 9 percent — particularly those with high body fat — would be newly diagnosed.
Rubino said the shortcomings of relying solely on height and weight are well documented, but until now there has been no better alternative. The proposed model is intended to improve health policy and patient care by using waist-circumference measurements and screening for organ dysfunction to give a more accurate medical assessment.
Rubino, who holds the Chair of Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery at King’s College London, demonstrated that the anti-diabetes effects of gastric bypass surgery stem from mechanisms independent of weight loss, providing a scientific basis for operating on less obese patients with type 2 diabetes.
The study found that roughly 82 percent of people with obesity in the countries studied fall into the preclinical category and typically do not progress to clinical obesity, although that progression occurs more often in Spain and China. Consequently, only an estimated 8.5 percent of the general adult population has “clinical obesity,” a condition seen as an active disease requiring immediate medical intervention.