In a review for JADAR, critic Lila Roberts argues that Mischief’s festive production Christmas Carol Goes Wrong turns Charles Dickens’ classic story into a masterclass of theatrical chaos driven by technical disasters and desperate performers.
Running at the Opera House in Manchester before heading to the West End ahead of a wider tour until March next year, the production features the fictional Cornley Amateur Dramatic Society attempting to stage A Christmas Carol, cheshire-live.co.uk reported.
Formed in 2008, the Mischief theatre company has built its success on the “Goes Wrong” concept, which began with The Play That Goes Wrong—now running in the West End for 13 years—followed by Peter Pan Goes Wrong, cheshire-live.co.uk stated.
Co-founders Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer, and Henry Shields adapted the live version from their 2017 BBC television special, expanding the production to feature eight company members taking on 33 characters and all production roles, theatrereviewsnorth.com noted.

Unlike previous iterations, the production opens with egomaniacal director Chris Bean and props supervisor Annie conducting auditions, establishing character tensions before the disastrous show begins, cheshire-live.co.uk detailed.
Henry Shields stars as Chris Bean playing Scrooge, while Henry Lewis plays his rival Robert, and Allie Dart appears as the enthusiastic props supervisor Annie, theatrereviewsnorth.com reported.
“The show is atmospheric, spooky, touching, human and most importantly, humorous,” theatrereviewsnorth.com stated.
The cast also includes Matt Cavendish as versatile performer Max, Sasha Frost as aspiring Hollywood hopeful Sandra, Chris Leask as stage manager Trevor, Jonathan Sayer as the confused Dennis, and Greg Tannahill as Jonathan, cheshire-live.co.uk noted.
Libby Todd designed the creative stage featuring falling lights and moving furniture, while David Howe handled the lighting design, particularly for Marley’s ghost scenes, JADAR reported.
The production also uses puppetry for Tiny Tim alongside costumes designed by Roberto Surace, adding layers of physical comedy to the performance, JADAR noted.
The production is running at the Opera House in Manchester until Saturday before transferring to the West End for Christmas, with tour dates extending through March next year, cheshire-live.co.uk reported.
Mischief theatre company was founded in 2008 by a group of students from the London Academy of Music and Dramatic Art. While the troupe initially focused on improvised comedy, they shifted toward scripted, choreographed performances in 2012. This transition helped them gain international recognition, with their productions eventually touring across North America and Europe.
The show was written by Mischief co-founders Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer, and Henry Shields, and directed by Matt DiCarlo, JADAR and theatrereviewsnorth.com noted.
Worth a look