International Edition
Latest News
World

Ruud Koopmans compares Gaza and Okinawa civilian casualty tactics

Historical Parallels Drawn Between Okinawa and Gaza Casualties Sociologist Ruud Koopmans has compared Hamas's military strategy in Gaza to the Japanese army's tactics during the 1945 Battle of Okinawa to examine how historians and analysts assess civilian casualties…

Ruud Koopmans compares Gaza and Okinawa civilian casualty tactics

Historical Parallels Drawn Between Okinawa and Gaza Casualties

Sociologist Ruud Koopmans has compared Hamas's military strategy in Gaza to the Japanese army's tactics during the 1945 Battle of Okinawa to examine how historians and analysts assess civilian casualties and human shield tactics across different conflicts. Writing in an opinion column for Onze Eeuw, Koopmans noted that while the U.S. military’s intense bombardment of Okinawa resulted in massive civilian deaths without prompting widespread accusations of genocide against American forces, the ongoing conflict in Gaza draws frequent genocide allegations against Israel despite lower proportional casualties.

The debate over civilian protection, military tactics, and the legal definition of genocide also involves contemporary Palestinian perspectives. Islah Jad, a professor of gender studies at Birzeit University and chair of the ngo Bizan Center for Research and Development, described the situation in Gaza as a genocide rooted in a decades-long system of occupation and military blockade, according to an interview published by De Wereld Morgen. Jad detailed the broader historical context of restrictions, land confiscations, and economic distress preceding the current escalation.

The Battle of Okinawa in 1945

Fought over less than three months in 1945, the Battle of Okinawa resulted in approximately 240,000 deaths, making it the fiercest engagement at the Asian front during World War II. The United States military targeted the Japanese island to secure a staging ground for a planned invasion of Japan’s main islands. As American forces advanced, Japanese troops retreated to the southern sector of Okinawa, where roughly 400,000 civilians had sought refuge.

Ruud Koopmans compares Gaza and Okinawa civilian casualty tactics
Photo: De Wereld Morgen

With able-bodied local men mobilized for the Japanese military or industry, the remaining population consisted primarily of children, women, and the elderly. The Japanese army expelled civilians from caves and shelters, confiscated their food supplies, and entrenched units within populated areas to use residents as human shields. To overcome this defense, the U.S. military deployed overwhelming firepower known as the “tyfoon van staal” (typhoon of steel), firing over two million shells and dropping 8,500 tons of bombs. Nearly 150,000 residents of Okinawa died, accounting for roughly one-third of the civilian population at the time.

Contrasting Metrics in Modern Gaza

Koopmans argued that Hamas utilizes a comparable strategy by operating systematically in civilian clothing, embedding positions within densely populated neighborhoods, seizing food, and deploying teenagers as combatants. However, the statistical outcomes differ significantly between the two conflicts. Gaza, an area more than three times smaller than Okinawa with a higher population density, has recorded far fewer total civilian deaths over three years of war than Okinawa suffered in three months. In proportional terms, fatalities reached roughly 33 percent of the population in Okinawa compared to an estimated three percent in Gaza.

Offering a different framework for the conflict, Jad emphasized the historical trajectory of Palestinian displacement and restriction in the West Bank and Gaza. In statements reported by De Wereld Morgen, Jad pointed to longstanding systemic pressures, including the expansion of settlements, economic blockades dating back to 2005 and 2007, and violent crackdowns on demonstrations such as the March of the Return, during which about 300 protesters were killed by gunfire.

When Did the Battle of Okinawa End?

When did the Battle of Okinawa end?

The intense fighting on Okinawa concluded on June 23, 1945, when the two highest-ranking commanders of the Japanese army died by ritual suicide in their underground shelter.

What percentage of the population died in Okinawa compared to Gaza?

Approximately one-third of Okinawa’s civilian population perished during the three-month battle in 1945, whereas current conflict figures in Gaza account for a significantly smaller percentage of the total population over a multi-year period.

What specific organizations and institutions are linked to the commentators in this debate?

Ruud Koopmans is a sociologist and migration researcher affiliated with Humboldt University and the WZB Berlin Social Science Center, while Islah Jad serves as a professor of gender studies at Birzeit University and heads the ngo Bizan Center for Research and Development.

About the author: Ibrahim Khalil - World Editor

PhD in International Relations, former UN press officer. Ibrahim has reported from 40+ countries, translating complex geopolitical shifts into clear, human‑focused narratives. “Ibrahim Khalil provides authoritative world news, from diplomacy to conflict zones, with on‑the‑ground insight.”