Taylor Swift released the four-track “Encore” edition of her 12th album, “The Life of a Showgirl,” on Friday, drawing a mix of sharp fan criticism and a one-star review from Page Six. The surprise drop includes the tracks “Patient Zero,” “Babylon,” “Pink Clouding,” and “Cleveland!” rather than burnishing the original album’s reputation, the new release intensified what reviewers characterize as a persistent identity crisis.
### Exploring the ‘Encore‘ Tracklist: From Girl’s Anthems to Travis Kelce Tributes
The four new songs span widely divergent musical styles, echoing sonic eras from Swift’s past catalog. “Patient Zero” adopts the moody aesthetic of “The Tortured Poets Department,” while “Babylon” and “Pink Clouding” recall the production styles of “Folklore” and “Midnights,” respectively.
The most discussed addition to the tracklist is “Cleveland!,” an explicit nod to her husband, NFL star Travis Kelce. The song features direct lyrics about the athlete, including:
> “He already took me to Cleveland / And he showed me The Heights / so hate all you like (Uh-huh) / This is the love of my life.”
Another line on the track features the lyric, “The taste of me is acquired, but it’s his favorite dish.” Critical response to “Cleveland!” centers on its overt sentimentality and polarizing phrasing.
### Fan Reactions and Critical Reception on Social Media
Public reception on platforms like X (formerly Twitter) was largely divided. While Swift confirmed in promotional statements that “Patient Zero” functions as a dedicated anthem for female friendship, and listeners theorized that “Pink Clouding” addresses her 2016 relationship with actor Tom Hiddleston, the broader internet reaction remained skeptical.
Disappointed listeners voiced frustration online, with one user writing on X, “Showgirl really her weakest work not even the encore could save this.” Another commenter posted, “Does she know it’s ok to keep songs in the vault?”
Despite the negative social media feedback and a scathing one-out-of-four-star review from Page Six, industry observers note that Swift’s commercial durability remains unmatched. Commentators point out that her current output reflects a happier, settled personal life compared to the heartbreak-fueled writing of her earlier career, ensuring her continued dominance on the pop music stage.
Related reading