TikToker Ordered to Pay $10 Million in Defamation Lawsuit Over Idaho Murder Accusations

BOISE, Idaho — A federal jury has awarded $10 million in damages to University of Idaho professor Rebecca Scofield after finding TikTok creator Ashley Guillard liable for defamation. The verdict, reached on February 27, 2026, stems from Guillard’s repeated false accusations that Scofield was involved in the November 2022 murders of four University of Idaho students Idaho News 6, Idaho Statesman.

False Accusations and Online Spread

Following the tragic deaths of Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin, Guillard posted dozens of videos on TikTok falsely claiming Scofield orchestrated the murders and had an inappropriate romantic relationship with a student US Magazine. These claims quickly spread online, garnering millions of views and causing significant harm to Scofield’s reputation and well-being.

Jury Deliberation and Damages Awarded

A federal judge had previously ruled that Guillard’s statements were defamatory, leaving the determination of damages to a jury. After deliberating for just under two hours, the jury awarded Scofield $3.5 million for the false claims regarding an inappropriate relationship and $6.5 million for the allegations related to the murders East Idaho News.

Scofield’s Response

In a statement following the verdict, Scofield expressed gratitude to the jury for their time and attention. She emphasized that the decision reinforces the importance of accountability for false statements made online and sends a clear message that such actions have real-world consequences. Scofield also expressed hope that this difficult chapter in her life is over and she can return to a more normal life with her family and the Moscow community Idaho News 6.

Guillard’s Defense and Trial Proceedings

Guillard, who represented herself throughout the proceedings, testified that she believes she has psychic abilities and used tarot card readings to try and solve the murders East Idaho News. The trial was presided over by Judge Raymond E. Patricco of the United States District Court for the District of Idaho.

Related Cases

This case comes after Bryan Kohberger, the individual arrested in connection with the student murders, was ordered to pay $3,000 to the victims’ families Idaho News 6.