Two Dallas police officers filed a federal lawsuit against the city of Dallas and five department officials over sex discrimination and retaliation claims tied to their fugitive unit assignments, CBS News reported.
Senior Corporal Kimberly Howard, a 19-year department veteran with 49 commendations and awards, and Officer Meredith Leftwich filed the action in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, according to reporting by the Dallas Observer.
The federal complaint states that the department downgraded four female officers from the fugitive unit in 2025, shifting their status from operational to partially operational, FOX 4 News reported. The suit names tactical training group officers and fugitive unit commander Maj. Gerald Smalley as defendants alongside the department.
Attorneys for the plaintiffs argue that removing women from primary fugitive unit duties and questioning their physical qualifications created a hostile work environment. “To be disposed of, discarded and dismissed is an offense against humanity that must be made right,” JoDee Neil, an attorney representing Howard and Leftwich, told CBS News.
According to the lawsuit, female officers assigned to the fugitive unit faced removal from full-scale operations and received unfair evaluations that included questions about their physical stature or whether they were too nice to pull the trigger, CBS News reported. Male officers told plaintiffs that one officer was shifted because of her physical stature while another was called too nice to pull the trigger, the Dallas Observer noted.
Both Howard and Leftwich have since returned to full operational status in the unit, but their lawsuit alleges they faced retaliation after challenging their treatment through internal grievances that reached Dallas Police Chief Daniel Comeaux.

“I think that everything you see here reflects a hostile work environment that treats high-qualified, dependable, trustworthy females as disposable,” Neil told FOX 4 News.
Jennifer Atherton, president of the Dallas Police Women’s Association, described the restrictions as benching and said gender bias played a role in the decisions, CBS News reported. Atherton said that Major Smalley asked her how many women were in SWAT and said that maybe there was a reason none were currently serving there, according to FOX 4 News.
Neither Howard nor Leftwich spoke on the record regarding the litigation. The Dallas Police Department declined to comment on pending litigation, and the City of Dallas similarly declined to comment, according to CBS News and FOX 4 News.
Related reading