International Edition
Latest News
World

UN Conference Ends Without Mandate for Binding Autonomous Weapons Rules

Delegates from 128 member states concluded a weeklong United Nations conference in Geneva on Saturday without securing an agreement to negotiate legally binding rules on autonomous weapon systems, according to reporting by The Guardian. The conference, operating under…

UN Conference Ends Without Mandate for Binding Autonomous Weapons Rules

Delegates from 128 member states concluded a weeklong United Nations conference in Geneva on Saturday without securing an agreement to negotiate legally binding rules on autonomous weapon systems, according to reporting by The Guardian.

The conference, operating under the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, ended with countries agreeing only to “elaborate” a possible accord by 2028 rather than committing to binding prohibitions, AP News reported. The outcome missed a 2026 deadline established by UN Secretary-General António Guterres and ICRC President Mirjana Spoljaric Egger.

“We’re starting to see artificial intelligence … being fielded in the battlefield and perhaps also already in weapon systems. If we leave this unregulated, it will be much more difficult to put the genie back in the bottle,” said Dr Cordula Droege, the director of international law, movement and partnerships at the International Committee of the Red Cross.

“We're very close to crossing those red lines, particularly targeting human beings through machines should be a moral red line,” said Dr Cordula Droege, the director of international law, movement and partnerships at the International Committee of the Red Cross.

Military Powers Resist Binding Restrictions

Major military powers, including the United States, Russia, and Israel, strongly resisted binding limitations during the Geneva sessions, according to Reuters and AP News. AP News reported that activists accused Russia and the United States of blocking stronger language to maintain freedom in developing high-tech arms.

UN Conference Ends Without Mandate for Binding Autonomous Weapons Rules
Photo: Vatican News

Of the major world powers present, only China expressed willingness to move toward a legally binding international protocol, U.N. sources noted. Meanwhile, the Holy See submitted a position paper calling for a moratorium on lethal autonomous weapons, arguing that decisions over life and death must remain in human hands, Vatican News reported.

“No algorithm can make war morally acceptable,” the Holy See stated in its paper, warning that machines calculate while moral judgment requires conscience.

Civil Society Warns of Rising Civilian Harm

Human rights organizations criticized the conference outcome as inadequate against rapidly accelerating military technology. Al Jazeera reported that the Stop Killer Robots coalition termed the mandate watered down and lacking a clear route to legally binding rules.

“Delaying the creation of a legally binding instrument puts civilians and humanity at risk,” said Nicole van Rooijen, the executive director of Stop Killer Robots, as cited by U.N. sources.

Why have UN efforts to regulate ‘killer robots’ stalled
Photo: Al Jazeera

The Guardian reported several instances of civilian casualties involving automated and AI-assisted military systems, including a Russian drone guided by an AI system that killed three civilians in Zaporizhzhia in July, and AI-assisted targeting methods used by Israel in Gaza. Anna Hehir, the head of military AI governance at the Future of Life Institute, warned that further delays risk mass casualty events driven by autonomous drone swarms facing algorithmic errors.

Unpredictable Risks of Combat Systems

The International Committee of the Red Cross highlighted that autonomous weapons can prove unpredictable, unlike a bullet fired from a gun that follows a distinct and predictable trajectory, according to AP News.

AP News noted that U.N. High Representative for Disarmament Affairs Izumi Nakamitsu urged countries to begin work promptly and start thinking about how to get as strong a treaty as possible to prohibit and regulate lethal autonomous weapon systems. Meanwhile, Vatican News reported that the Holy See revived its 2021 proposal for an International Organization for Artificial Intelligence to monitor peaceful uses, comparing it to bodies overseeing outer space activities.

Rights Groups Criticize Lack of Urgent Action

Human Rights Watch’s Verity Coyle stated that the outcome lacked the urgent action required to agree on new rules while the technology races ahead, according to source reporting.

united nations geneva diplomacy flags Photo Credit: Xabi Oregi, Pexels
Photo: Eurasia Review

However, Stop Killer Robots lamented a watered-down mandate, while international law advocacy voices and civil society campaigners observed that most countries had supported work toward a new treaty.

Path Forward to 2028

While the conference rejected a direct mandate to negotiate a binding treaty, Swiss conference chair Julien Thöni defended the decision to continue discussions as proof that multilateral diplomacy can still deliver results amid geopolitical tensions, according to U.N. sources. Startup Fortune noted that all 128 states party to the convention backed the Geneva outcome.

“The agreed text refers instead to the ‘elaboration’ of an instrument,” Al Jazeera reported, noting that the 2028 deadline leaves the final legal status of the document unresolved.

The International Committee of the Red Cross maintains a long-standing mandate to promote and ensure respect for the 1949 Geneva Conventions and their Additional Protocols. Established by state parties to protect victims of armed conflict, the organization utilizes this authority to influence international humanitarian law.

By advocating for strict adherence to these established protections, the International Committee of the Red Cross actively shapes disarmament negotiations, pressing nations to address the moral and legal implications of emerging technologies within the framework of their established humanitarian mission.

“States need to deliver the majority’s call for a new treaty,” said Bonnie Docherty, a senior arms adviser to Human Rights Watch, according to U.N. sources.

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.