A Dutch environmental group has lodged the first complaint of its kind through the European Commission, claiming New Zealand broke climate change commitments under its free trade agreement with the European Union.
Both ENDS Files Precedent-Setting Single Entry Point Complaint Over Paris Agreement Commitments
The environmental organisation Both ENDS filed the legal challenge using the European Commission’s Single Entry Point mechanism. The group claims New Zealand failed to uphold legal commitments in the EU-NZ Free Trade Agreement not to weaken environmental protections to encourage trade or investment, and to effectively implement the Paris Agreement. Two-way trade between New Zealand and the EU reached approximately $21.5 billion last year. When the trade deal was signed in 2022, former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern described it as containing new, unprecedented commitments on the environment and labour rights. The agreement officially entered into force on 1 May 2024.
Government Defends Policy Changes Against European Trade Scrutiny
The Trade Minister rejected the intervention, stating it is not for overseas countries, organisations, or lobby groups to tell New Zealand how to meet its obligations. Both ENDS argued that the New Zealand government enacted a series of connected decisions weakening domestic climate safeguards since the trade deal took effect. The complaint cites a projected 84 million-tonne emissions shortfall, a weakened methane target, the removal of agriculture from carbon pricing, the reversal of the offshore oil and gas exploration ban, a $200 million Gas Security Fund, a planned LNG import facility, and legislation preventing climate-related claims against major emitters. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon noted in June that “we ain’t sending billions of dollars offshore” for mitigation. Meanwhile, Deputy Prime Minister David Seymour dismissed local co-sponsors of the complaint—including health professionals from OraTaiao—as activists with a grab bag of causes.
New Zealand Organisations Join Dutch Challenge as Co-Sponsors
While domestic organisations cannot directly file a complaint through the Single Entry Point, several New Zealand groups and individuals joined as co-sponsors. Supporters include Greenpeace, Ngāti Pukenga, Ora Taiao, the Environmental Law Initiative, Mike Smith, and Professor Jane Kelsey. Both ENDS stated that the mechanism exists for European civil society to ask the Commission to enforce sustainability commitments in trade agreements. The Dutch NGO is seeking compliance rather than the suspension of trade benefits, though the agreement allows for trade penalties at the conclusion of an extended legal process.
Next Legal Steps in European Commission Review
The European Commission will review the submission from Both ENDS to determine whether the complaint establishes that the New Zealand government has been unresponsive to traditional consultative processes. No date has been announced by the Commission for an initial decision on the case.
Related reading