Michael Tobias, a 38-year-old Harrisburg man who had recently rebuilt his life after a long struggle with addiction, died on Sept. 23 while fishing at Memorial Lake in East Hanover Township.
He collapsed near the water’s edge while with a friend and did not regain consciousness, according to PennLive.
While Pennsylvania State Police initially investigated the incident as a drowning, the Lebanon County coroner’s office later determined his death was natural. An autopsy revealed he died from hypertensive atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, a condition involving high blood pressure and plaque buildup in the arteries. His family stated they were unaware he had underlying heart issues.
Tobias had been sober for about three months at the time of his death, having recently completed a rehabilitation program. Family members described this period as a return to the person they knew best—healthy, optimistic, and deeply focused on his four children. He had been planning a move to North Carolina to be closer to them.
“After rehab he was a totally different person,” his sister, Brittany Gardner, told PennLive. “He was the Mike that everyone knew that I grew up with. The Mike that made everybody proud, and the Mike that everybody wanted to be around.”
His father, Paul Tobias, said that the death of Michael’s 15-year-old daughter, Serenity, in 2024 had caused him great grief. Paul Tobias said that in their final conversation, Michael mentioned feeling unwell and intending to schedule an MRI for persistent headaches.
Before his death, Tobias worked as a mechanic at Momos Automotive in Harrisburg. Representatives for the shop described him as a vital member of their team who brought both hard work and humor to the workplace.
“He was not just an employee; he was family,” a representative for Momos Automotive told PennLive. “We are so hurt and heartbroken over his loss.”
Raised in Newport, Perry County, Tobias was known to his friends and family as an outdoorsman who enjoyed repairing cars, installing stereo systems, and visiting shooting ranges. Sergej Jagodin, a close friend, remembered Tobias as a resilient and loyal presence.
“He always made me feel protected,” Jagodin told PennLive. “He was definitely an older brother to me.”
The circumstances of his passing at Memorial Lake in Lebanon County drew attention due to the initial assessment by state police. The coroner’s report clarified that the collapse was a result of his cardiovascular condition rather than the lake environment.
Gardner expressed that the family finds some solace in the belief that he is reunited with his daughter. “It’s definitely the worst thing in the world right now,” she said. “But the only thing that’s giving me any type of comfort is reminding myself every single day that he’s now with Serenity.”
Related reading