An Alabama jury acquitted Reuben Gulley of murder on Friday in the 2022 shooting death of Randon Lee, the 18-year-old son of TikTok creator Ophelia Nichols, after deliberating for about 90 minutes.
The verdict ends a case that hinged on conflicting accounts of a drug deal outside a Prichard gas station. Gulley, 25, admitted he shot Lee but testified he acted in self-defense after Lee pulled a gun inside the vehicle. Prosecutors argued Gulley fired to avoid paying $300 for two ounces of marijuana.
Lee died on June 24, 2022, after Gulley approached his car at a Pride gas station in Prichard, north of Mobile. Security footage showed Gulley, wearing a hood, moving from a passenger seat to Lee’s driver-side window. The video did not capture the shooting but recorded Gulley running back to a waiting car with a gun in his hand as Lee drove away.
Gulley testified Thursday that he entered the back seat of Lee’s car and produced 15 $20 bills before Lee allegedly drew a weapon. His attorney, Chase Dearman, told jurors the Prichard Police Department conducted a poor investigation, noting detectives never explained how a single shot could leave a bullet lodged in Lee’s body while also piercing the windshield.
“Of course, I’m satisfied, but more than anything else, I am relieved,” Dearman told WALA-TV after the verdict. “I laid awake all night thinking certainly a Mobile County jury could not find somebody guilty on this kind of evidence, and I’m very, very happy.”
Nichols, known to more than 12 million TikTok followers as “Mama Tot,” said her husband wept in the courtroom when the foreman read the verdict.
“I have watched my husband break down sitting in that courtroom today while I did my best to hold it together for myself, for him, my children, our entire family,” Nichols wrote on Facebook. “As I could feel the excited energy from the other side because their son was coming home, I slowly melted into my seat. Knowing that Justice had been stripped from my son and us, I couldn’t even describe what it did to my soul.”
Mobile County Chief Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Susman acknowledged investigative shortcomings but said the state proceeded on independent corroborating evidence.
“There’s no denying that all of the issues with the Prichard Police Department have created a distraction to the jurors, and I believe that defense attorneys are trying to take full advantage of that,” Susman said.
“I’m very hopeful that as we continue to fight for justice, people will be able to focus on the veracity of the other evidence, and ultimately the right outcomes will be a result.”
Nichols said the family still does not know how the jury reached its decision.
“We don’t know what, why or how the jurors came to that decision and I’m sure we will question that moment the rest of our lives,” she wrote. “No remorse for our family. Zero regards for Randon’s life. What was done to our family was downright cruel and knowing that we are not alone in these situations is scary.”
Worth a look