International Edition
Latest News
World

Analysts Urge Umno to Take Accountability for Past Governance Failures

Mazlan Ali argues Umno must accept political accountability Umno cannot expect voters to acknowledge its time in power if it simultaneously disavows the mistakes made during its rule, according to Mazlan Ali, a political analyst from Universiti Teknologi…

Analysts Urge Umno to Take Accountability for Past Governance Failures

Mazlan Ali argues Umno must accept political accountability

Umno cannot expect voters to acknowledge its time in power if it simultaneously disavows the mistakes made during its rule, according to Mazlan Ali, a political analyst from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia. Blaming individual officials or company directors is not good enough when senior appointments and major policies come under the purview of ministers from the party, Mazlan added.

“Political accountability differs from legal liability,” he said. The party still has a duty to admit shortcomings in its political oversight and back reforms designed to stop similar errors from happening again, even while legal processes are allowed to unfold, he noted.

Pointing to 1MDB, Tabung Haji, and the littoral combat ship project, Mazlan said their lasting financial and security implications remain relevant to voters assessing the party’s ability to govern. These are not merely past controversies, he argued, as their repercussions continue to affect public finances and national capabilities.

Demonstrating Genuine Renewal

Mazlan said Umno needs to demonstrate genuine renewal rather than rely solely on its historical governing experience. Leadership opportunities should be extended to figures untainted by prior scandals, alongside efforts to ensure internal party polls are conducted with greater openness, he observed.

“Umno needs to establish a clear policy regarding the suspension or expulsion of members convicted of corruption or abuse of power without political compromise,” Mazlan said. Furthermore, the party ought to back stricter background checks for government-linked corporate and ministerial roles, clearer procurement processes, and policy changes that curtail ministerial powers, he remarked.

Awang Azman Pawi highlights Umno's institutional contributions

Universiti Malaya’s Awang Azman Pawi argued that it is unjust to boil down Umno’s many years in office to scandals like Tabung Haji and 1MDB, or to let the actions of a few bad actors brand the whole organization.

“We must distinguish between individual wrongdoing, institutional weaknesses, and the broader contributions of a political party,” Awang Azman said. He said that the party’s past efforts in rural growth, schooling, the industrial sector, and organizations like Mara and Felda serve as valid benchmarks for evaluating its administrative track record.

Awang Azman stressed that rules of accountability must remain consistent across all governments rather than shifting to suit political agendas. At the same time, he cautioned that Umno must not hide behind its developmental achievements to sidestep addressing flaws in its governance and supervision.

“Umno’s historical record remains an asset, provided it can demonstrate that the party has learned from its shortcomings,” Awang Azman added.

Questions about Umno's past projects and analyst affiliations

What specific projects were cited by analysts regarding Umno’s past administration?

Analysts pointed to 1MDB, Tabung Haji, and the littoral combat ship project as controversies with lasting financial and security implications for public finances.

Which academic institutions are the analysts affiliated with?

Mazlan Ali is from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, and Awang Azman Pawi is from Universiti Malaya.

What institutional contributions did Awang Azman Pawi cite as part of Umno’s record?

He highlighted past government efforts in education, rural development, industrialisation, and institutions such as Felda and Mara.

About the author: Ibrahim Khalil - World Editor

PhD in International Relations, former UN press officer. Ibrahim has reported from 40+ countries, translating complex geopolitical shifts into clear, human‑focused narratives. “Ibrahim Khalil provides authoritative world news, from diplomacy to conflict zones, with on‑the‑ground insight.”