Annual fees on credit cards are worth it only if the value of the rewards and benefits you use exceeds the cost of the fee. Responsible cardholders who pay their balance in full each month and use benefits regularly can find significant value, but those who carry a balance will likely lose money due to high interest charges.
Credit card issuers charge an annual fee to pay for the enhanced rewards and exclusive benefits that come with a card. Whether the fee is justified depends entirely on a cardholder’s spending habits, lifestyle, and ability to pay the balance in full each month.
What exactly is an annual fee for?
An annual fee is essentially a membership fee, according to Ted Rossman. It allows issuers to support the perks that come with being a cardholder, such as cash back, airline miles, and travel benefits. The average annual credit card fee is $127, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).
What are the risks of an annual fee?
The primary risk of carrying a card with an annual fee is the cost of interest if you don’t pay your balance in full.
Another risk is paying the fee for benefits you never use.
How do you calculate if a fee is worth it?
To determine if an annual fee is worth it, add up the potential value of the rewards you think you will use. If that total is more than the fee, the card may be a good choice.
For instance, a card with a $95 annual fee offers 5% cash back on groceries and 3% on gas. Spending $100 weekly on groceries and $50 weekly on gas would yield the full annual value of those two benefits, easily covering the fee. However, if you carry a $3,000 balance on that same card at 22% APR, you would pay an additional $369 in interest, making the card a net loss.
Annual fee cards vs. no-annual-fee cards
The fundamental difference between the two card types is the cost to own them. No-fee cards do not charge a recurring annual fee or maintenance fees. They typically still offer some rewards, like cash back, airline miles or redeemable points.
What are the alternatives to annual fee cards?
If an annual fee card doesn’t make sense, consider no-fee cards that still offer some rewards like cash back or airline miles. Balance transfer cards allow you to consolidate your debt onto one credit card without an annual fee.
Related reading