International Edition
Latest News
Technology

Attorney Won Hee-young Questions Ethics of Tax Exam Cheater’s YouTube Apology

A top-ranked candidate in South Korea’s 63rd certified tax accountant examination admitted to using electronic devices and generative artificial intelligence to cheat on both rounds of the test, delivering the confession on a defense attorney’s YouTube channel that…

Attorney Won Hee-young Questions Ethics of Tax Exam Cheater's YouTube Apology

A top-ranked candidate in South Korea’s 63rd certified tax accountant examination admitted to using electronic devices and generative artificial intelligence to cheat on both rounds of the test, delivering the confession on a defense attorney’s YouTube channel that logged 1.7 million views in its first 24 hours.

The video, posted November 15 on the channel of attorney Won Hee-young, became the most-viewed clip in the channel’s history within a single day, attracting 15,000 likes, Financial News reported. The successful examinee acknowledged cheating during the first and second exams and said a self-report had already been filed with the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency.

Won, a former Financial News reporter who now practices criminal law at YK Law Firm, wrote in a column that she would have advised the client to surrender given the digital trail such cheating leaves. Purchase records for prohibited devices and timestamped AI chat logs can later be matched against answer sheets, she noted, exposing not only the misconduct but any subsequent denials. Under Article 52 of the Criminal Act, voluntary surrender allows a court to reduce or exempt punishment, though the statute does not require a public apology or a video record.

Won questioned why the apology appeared on her channel rather than on the platform where the examinee previously posted a passing memoir and interviews that contained false statements. She said she would have directed the client to publish a written apology in the same venue so the candidates who trusted the original account could learn exactly which parts were fabricated. A brief statement from counsel to media could then announce the surrender, followed by submission of devices and evidence to police and the exam administrator.

The column also examined whether the video’s advertising revenue constitutes a prohibited contingency fee. The Supreme Court ruled in 2015 that success-fee agreements in criminal cases signed after that decision are void because tying compensation to case outcomes undermines trust in the justice system. In January, the Seoul Central District Court upheld a fee conditioned on an acquittal, but Won said that YouTube ad revenue — roughly 8.5 million won at an estimated 5 won per view — accrues regardless of the client’s disposition.

Won wrote that it is unclear who proposed the appearance. If she had suggested it, she said, she would have disclosed the potential benefit to her channel beforehand.

Criminal defendants are often in a vulnerable state and may regard counsel’s suggestions as a lifeline, she added. The video was re-edited into a Shorts clip the following day. Even if the original is later removed, copies can persist indefinitely, a risk the client must understand before agreeing to appear.

“A few years from now, when the client starts a new career, someone will search their name and find this apology,” Won wrote. “I cannot promise that every copy uploaded by others will be taken down. The client must know that before deciding.” She concluded that the ultimate goal is for the client to return to a peaceful life, and that permanent digital exposure makes that recovery harder.

About the author: Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archynewsy.