Winthrop Street Property Trust must drop its challenge against a preliminary injunction protecting solar farm settlement proceeds because the order is merely interlocutory, Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly reported.
“This is an appeal by Winthrop Street Property Trust from the Bankruptcy Court’s grant of a preliminary injunction to preserve proceeds of a settlement purportedly reached by the parties, Winthrop Street Property Trust and Winthrop Street-Morra Solar, LLC,” said U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor in Civil Action No. 02-604-26 (10 pages) according to the 26-10994-FDS court records.
U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor ruled that the trust failed to satisfy any statutory requirement for interlocutory certification. The underlying litigation stems from a November 5, 2014, lease agreement where predecessors of the trust and Winthrop Street-Morra Solar, LLC agreed to install and operate a solar farm on property located at 297 Winthrop Street in Rehoboth, Massachusetts.
The trust filed a lawsuit against the debtor in Bristol County Superior Court on October 14, 2021, citing a failure to comply with lease terms. The debtor responded with contractual counterclaims on November 12, 2021, and the parties disputed whether a valid settlement was reached before the debtor filed for bankruptcy.
On May 18, 2025, the debtor filed a voluntary Chapter 11 petition in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Massachusetts. The debtor removed the superior court action to the Bankruptcy Court on August 15, 2025, initiating the current adversary proceeding.
The debtor moved for a preliminary injunction on November 7, 2025, asking the court to prevent the trust from dissipating proceeds from the disputed pre-petition settlement. The Bankruptcy Court held a hearing on February 5, 2026, and entered an order granting the injunction on February 9, 2026.
The trust filed a notice of appeal to the District Court on February 23, 2026. Judge Saylor found that the preliminary injunction is interlocutory because significant issues remain unresolved in the adversary proceeding.
The court evaluated the appeal under the standard set by 28 U.S.C. Section 1292(b). Judge Saylor determined that the order does not involve a controlling question of law because challenging the Bankruptcy Court’s findings involves applying law to facts.
The legal issues are not unsettled, and a reversal would not terminate the litigation. The Bankruptcy Court must still rule on a motion to remand, which requires determining the status of the settlement and the general claims.
“The bankruptcy code authorizes district courts to hear appeals from final orders of the Bankruptcy Court, but requires a party to obtain leave of court to seek an appeal from a Bankruptcy Court’s interlocutory order,” according to Judge Saylor.
Worth a look