International Edition
Latest News
World

Campaigners Push to Raise Consent Age After Brand and Walliams Cases

The age of consent in England and Wales has stood at 16 since 1885, when a reported 250,000 people marched on Hyde Park demanding it be raised from 13, The Guardian reported. The law — formally the Criminal…

Campaigners Push to Raise Consent Age After Brand and Walliams Cases

The age of consent in England and Wales has stood at 16 since 1885, when a reported 250,000 people marched on Hyde Park demanding it be raised from 13, The Guardian reported.

The law — formally the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1885 — followed the Pall Mall Gazette’s “Maiden Tribute of Modern Babylon” series, in which editor W.T. Stead purchased 13-year-old Eliza Armstrong for £5 to prove children were being sold for sex.

Armstrong was drugged with chloroform and examined to verify her virginity before Stead “rescued” her; the exposé triggered riots outside the newspaper’s offices and forced Parliament’s hand, The Guardian reported.

More than 140 years later, the conviction of Russell Brand for rape and sexual assault and allegations against David Walliams, which he has denied, have returned the consent age to public debate. Investigations by the Guardian and other outlets revealed both men had sexual relationships with 16-year-olds while in their 30s, prompting campaigners to argue the current law fails to address power imbalances between teenagers and much older adults.

Staggered consent proposal

Mia Latter, who alleged she was raped by Brand when she was 16 and he was 30, told The Guardian: “I think we all agree that adults shouldn’t be allowed to have sexual relationships with children, with somebody under the age of 18.”

Layla Stone, a child protection social worker who leads the Close the Consent Gap campaign, said 16- and 17-year-olds are treated as children “in every single framework of the law.” The group proposes a staggered model: sex with 16- and 17-year-olds would become illegal for adults more than four years older than them.

Campaigners Push to Raise Consent Age After Brand and Walliams Cases
Photo: The Telegraph

A personal essay in The Telegraph supported the principle. The author, who dated a man in his mid-30s at 17, wrote: “The truth is that a big age gap necessarily comes with an imbalance of power. If you’re lucky, the man (or woman) won’t exploit it, but if they wanted to? Chances are, you wouldn’t notice. Not at 16.”

Legal inconsistencies across the UK

The 1885 law applied only to unmarried girls. Female children could marry at 12 until 1929, and inside marriage their sexual acquiescence was assumed, according to Laura Lammasniemi, assistant professor of law at the University of Warwick.

“If the sexual behaviour was somehow considered to be potentially harmful, you needed a higher age to consent to it than you did for something like marriage, which was considered to be generally a social good,” she told The Guardian.

Same-sex consent ages followed a different timetable. Sex between men was partly decriminalised at 21 in 1967, equalised to 16 only in 2000; lesbian sex did not appear in English law until 2003. Northern Ireland maintained an age of 17 from 1950 until equalisation in 2008.

International variation

Headline ages of consent vary widely, though close-in-age exemptions and authority-figure provisions often modify the headline number:

Country / Region Headline Age of Consent
Italy, Germany, Brazil, much of Central America 14
France, Sweden 15
England, Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland 16
Ireland, Cyprus, South Australia, Texas (US) 17
California, Florida and 12 other US states 18
Argentina (in some circumstances) 13

Adulthood as a moving target

Rachel Thomson, professor of childhood and youth studies at the University of Sussex, told The Guardian that while the age of first intercourse fell sharply in the late 20th century, the gap until first live-in relationship or first child — traditional markers of adulthood — has widened dramatically.

“There has been a real transformation of the scaffolding outside of the family that makes it possible to become autonomous and independent in the world,” Thomson said. The post-war model of leaving school at 16, walking into a job and starting a family in one’s 20s is “largely obsolete.” Many young people now experience “yo-yo transitions, going backwards and forwards from home to independence.”

Neuroscience reinforces the complexity. Sarah-Jayne Blakemore, professor of psychology and cognitive neuroscience at the University of Cambridge, wrote in a recent paper: “There is no single age at which the human brain can be universally classified as ‘adult’, as neurodevelopment is a continuous process without sharp transition points, marked by substantial individual variation.” Some experts argue adolescence should be redefined to span ages 10–24.

Age 18 is not a single adulthood milestone

In most of the world, 18 marks the major legal transition to adulthood and voting rights.

“This idea that we have this magic boundary at 18, that has never really existed,” Christine Huebner said. “The rights that young people acquire are really staggered at different ages — and probably for good reason.”

Her research tracking young adults aged 15–21 found they cited concrete milestones — donating blood at 17, starting a first job, driving, graduating — as moments they felt “adult,” arriving at different times for different people.

Carey Oppenheim, who led a Nuffield Foundation project on early adulthood, said pathways have become “more complex, longer and more precarious — and they remain very unequal.” She warned that specialist mental health services and other supports often stop abruptly at 18.

“The cliff edge at the age of 18, or wherever that cliff edge is, is not a very good way to organise support for young people as they navigate their transitions into adulthood,” Oppenheim said. Her report recommended recognising early adulthood as a distinct, extended phase rather than a single-day attainment.

About the author: World Desk

World Desk at Archynewsy.