The Supreme Court of Canada will hear arguments on March 22 and 23 regarding Saskatchewan’s school pronoun law and the province’s use of the notwithstanding clause to shield it from legal challenges.
The provincial legislation, adopted in 2023, mandates that students under 16 must obtain parental consent before changing their names or pronouns in school, according to reporting by Le Devoir. The government of Premier Scott Moe invoked the notwithstanding clause of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms to prevent the law from being challenged in court.
The upcoming hearings will address whether courts possess the authority to issue a declaratory judgment on a law when a government has specifically invoked the notwithstanding clause. This clause allows provincial governments to bypass certain Charter-guaranteed rights, provided the declaration is renewed every five years, as noted by L’Actualité.
The court will hear arguments from the Saskatchewan government and UR Pride, an LGBTQ organization based in Regina, according to Lechodelaval.
- 2023: Saskatchewan adopts legislation requiring parental consent for students under 16 to change their pronouns or names at school.
- March 22–23: The Supreme Court of Canada is scheduled to hear arguments from the province and UR Pride regarding the law and the notwithstanding clause.
What is the significance of the notwithstanding clause in this case?
The clause permits the government to override specific Charter rights. The Supreme Court must now determine if this invocation prevents the judiciary from issuing a declaratory judgment on the legislation’s validity.
The Supreme Court of Canada, which reached its current composition of nine justices in 1949, holds a unique position in the judicial system as a bilingual and bijural institution. It hears cases from both common law and civil law traditions in Canada’s two official languages.
While the court was established by an act passed on April 8, 1875, it did not serve as the final court of resort for all appeals until 1949. Before that time, litigants could bypass the court entirely to appeal decisions to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London, a practice that did not fully conclude until 1959.

Who is challenging the legislation?
The legal challenge is led by UR Pride, an LGBTQ advocacy group based in Regina, which argues against the provincial law’s restrictions on student identity.
Related reading