Director Zack Snyder is no longer attached to the upcoming remake of Escape from New York, according to John Carpenter.
The original creator confirmed the departure during a recent appearance on the Dropping Names with Brent and Jonny podcast.
“He’s not anymore, but he’s trying to get back,” Carpenter said of Snyder’s involvement. “He’s trying to get back. We’ll see. Nice man. I liked him.”
The project, a collaboration between StudioCanal and The Picture Company, first reported details regarding Snyder as the writer and director in June 2026.
The Rodriguez Contingency
Carpenter indicated that filmmaker Robert Rodriguez is currently positioned to take over the project should Snyder’s involvement fully lapse.
“We have a backup,” Carpenter said. “Robert Rodriguez, he has a new story he wants to do. So, we’ll see.”

This uncertainty follows a long line of directorial shifts for the remake. Over the years, filmmakers including Radio Silence, Leigh Whannell, Brett Ratner, Len Wiseman, Breck Eisner, and Neil Cross have all been attached to the project.
Studio Development Timeline
Development on the remake began in April 2026, when StudioCanal announced the new interpretation at CinemaCon. Carpenter remains attached to the production as an executive producer and has stated he intends to compose the score for the new version. According to reports from ComingSoon, Carpenter specifically demanded the opportunity to handle the music, which would see him return to his signature minimalist synth-style soundtracks.
Snyder Uncertain For “Escape From New York”?https://t.co/xlvsTMzZce pic.twitter.com/DVs4F9S9rc
Snyder had previously outlined a creative approach that would set the story in 1997 from the perspective of 1981, utilizing the original film’s timeline as a foundation.
Despite these early details, the studio has not yet confirmed a release date or casting for the role of Snake Plissken, the character famously originated by Kurt Russell in the 1981 thriller where a former Special Forces soldier is sent into Manhattan—which has been converted into a massive prison—to rescue the president following an Air Force One crash.
The Potential Directorial Shift
The transition toward Robert Rodriguez remains a point of speculation, as some observers clarify that the remarks regarding Snyder’s career trajectory were potentially misconstrued as a definitive departure from the project.
While reports from World of Reel initially framed the switch as a firm replacement, subsequent analysis suggests the production remains in a state of limbo. Fans of the 1981 original have expressed mixed reactions to the news, with some noting that the project has been “stuck” in development for years regardless of who occupies the director’s chair.

Critics of the potential move to Rodriguez have pointed out that his recent filmography lacks the critical acclaim of his earlier work, specifically referencing 2005’s Sin City. Meanwhile, some audiences have voiced concerns that any remake risks losing the unique appeal of Kurt Russell’s iconic portrayal of Snake Plissken.
Despite these doubts, Carpenter has confirmed that Rodriguez is prepared with an entirely new narrative approach for the film, should the studio decide to move forward in that direction.
Franchise Spans Decades with Mixed Reception
The franchise has seen various iterations over the decades. The 1981 original starred Russell alongside Lee Van Cleef and Donald Pleasence and was followed by the 1996 sequel Escape from L.A. In 2022, discussions regarding a new sequel began with 20th Century Studios, though those plans were abandoned two years later, according to Schnittberichte.
The project continues to face mixed public reception. While some contributors suggested that technical advancements could enhance the film’s visuals, many maintain that the 1981 original is a “masterpiece” that is difficult to replicate.
Other observers have questioned the shift in direction, noting that the status of the film remains “up in the air” as the studio manages the transition between directors. Some critics have pointed to the filmography of the potential successor, noting that Rodriguez has not directed a widely acclaimed film since Sin City, which he helmed alongside Frank Miller.
Worth a look