Chicago renters are facing volatile monthly costs as more landlords adopt the ratio utility billing system, a practice that divides master-metered building expenses among tenants without tracking individual usage.
While tenants previously paid predictable, flat fees for gas, water, and trash, the transition to this billing method—known as RUBS—has caused major, unpredictable changes in monthly housing costs, WBEZ reported.
For Maiko Lehman, a 56-year-old resident of Chicago’s Edgewater neighborhood, the shift in 2024 brought immediate instability. After moving into her apartment in 2022 with a known $100 flat monthly fee for utilities, her costs under the new third-party system, managed by Conservice, have ranged from $88.05 to $225.57, according to WBEZ.
Lehman said that because the formula remains opaque, she cannot verify if she is being charged accurately, and she lacks the ability to lower her costs through personal conservation.
“There's people in the building now who are flirting with [whether] they can afford the rent, and all of a sudden, this month the bill is higher for the utilities” said Maiko Lehman, 56.

The lack of individual meters in many older Chicago buildings allows landlords to outsource billing to companies like Conservice. “RUBS basically shifts risk of volatile, rising utility costs off of the landlords and onto the tenants” said Olivia Wein, a senior attorney at the National Consumer Law Center, told WBEZ that this system effectively transfers the risk of rising utility costs from building owners to residents.
| Resident | Former Monthly Utility Fee | Current RUBS Range |
|---|---|---|
| Maiko Lehman | $100 | $88.05 – $225.57 |
| Viola Davis | $105 | $150 – $220+ |
In the South Shore neighborhood, 85-year-old Viola Davis has faced similar financial strain at Oglesby Towers. Since her landlord, Stuart Handler and TLC Management, moved to the ratio system earlier this year, Davis has seen her monthly utility bills climb as high as $220, leaving her to struggle with the costs of daily essentials, WBEZ reported. Some of her neighbors have reported individual monthly utility charges reaching $500.
There is currently no state law in Illinois that prohibits the use of ratio utility billing, and no single agency holds regulatory authority over the third-party companies that issue these bills. The Illinois Commerce Commission, which typically regulates utility providers, said that it lacks authority over ratio metering, characterizing the issue as a private matter between tenants and landlords, according to WBEZ.
While state law requires landlords to provide notice before switching to a ratio billing system and grants tenants the right to view master utility bills, advocates argue these protections are insufficient. Mayor Brandon Johnson’s proposed Protecting Renters Ordinance, currently before the City Council, aims to codify these existing state-level protections, though it does not ban the practice, WBEZ reported.
Landlord organizations maintain that the billing method encourages efficiency. A spokesperson for the Illinois Apartment Association said that "RUBS provides an accurate estimate based on actual usage" and that a consistent formula promotes conservation. The Neighborhood Building Owners Alliance reported that approximately 10% of its members currently utilize this billing system.
In contrast, tenants are increasingly organizing to challenge the practice. Residents at Oglesby Towers formed a tenant union with the help of the nonprofit Southside Together to demand meetings with management regarding the variable costs.
During a press conference on October 27, 2026, resident Antoinette Gray stated she was facing eviction due to her inability to keep up with the fluctuating utility bills, telling the crowd, “Their response has been, ‘If you can’t pay, just leave,’” WBEZ reported.
Keep reading