Choo Mi-ae urges swift impeachment of Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae over ruling on Han Duck-soo
Gyeonggi Province Governor Choo Mi-ae called on the Democratic Party of Korea to move immediately on impeaching Supreme Court Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae, arguing the court’s recent decision clearing Acting President Han Duck-soo of insurrection charges sets a dangerous constitutional precedent.
Choo posted the demand to her Facebook page on the evening of May 21, criticizing fellow Democratic Party lawmakers with legal backgrounds who have expressed reservations about the impeachment push. She warned that hesitation would amount to tolerating a “judicial collapse” that grants impunity to accomplices of the Dec. 3 martial law declaration.
The Supreme Court ruled earlier this month that Han, who was prime minister at the time, did not meet the legal standard for “intent to subvert the constitutional order” required for an insurrection conviction. The majority opinion held that prosecutors needed to prove Han had concrete awareness of specific troop deployment plans and the sealing of key institutions, and that mere knowledge of the martial law decree was insufficient.
Choo, a former judge and justice minister, dismantled that reasoning in her statement. She cited the court’s own 1997 precedent in the Chun Doo-hwan case, which established that “awareness of the purpose of constitutional disruption” can be established by dolus eventualis — conditional intent — rather than requiring specific, proven knowledge of operational details.
She argued Han’s actions on the night of Dec. 3 satisfy even the stricter standard. Han received a briefing on the martial law plan from President Yoon Suk Yeol at 8:55 p.m., reviewed the decree document, and was present when then-Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun handed a directive document to then-Interior Minister Lee Sang-min — a document that included the banning of political activities and the suspension of warrants.
“Han Duck-soo had concrete awareness by being notified of the martial law proclamation plan in advance and reviewing the martial law document,” Choo wrote.
Beyond knowledge, Choo emphasized Han’s statutory role. As prime minister, Han chaired the Cabinet meeting that preceded the declaration.
Under Article 2, Clause 6 of the Martial Law Act, the defense and interior ministers are required to route their recommendation through the prime minister. Choo noted Han also stood first in the presidential line of succession, placing him in a “guarantor’s position” with a legal duty to prevent the Cabinet from rubber-stamping an unconstitutional act.
“He had a concrete duty to ensure substantive deliberation,” she wrote. “His failure to act — his omission — was unlawful.”
Choo rejected the majority’s insistence that Han needed to know exact troop numbers or which specific buildings would be sealed. Martial law inherently involves military mobilization and the suppression of dissent, she wrote; demanding granular foreknowledge of operational details is a “fabricated” standard that allows high-ranking officials to claim plausible deniability after facilitating a constitutional breach.
She described Han’s reported behavior that night — initially objecting on economic grounds, then passively attending the Cabinet meeting to check quorum after Kim Yong-hyun briefed him on preparations — as evidence of “passive participation” rather than resistance.
“The chief justice and the majority justices are sending a constitution-destroying message,” Choo wrote, “that a public official with authority and responsibility can cooperate with insurrection and later escape by simply claiming they did not accept the result.”
The Democratic Party leadership has not yet scheduled an impeachment vote. Party officials have signaled caution, citing the high bar for removing a sitting chief justice and the risk of a constitutional vacuum if the Constitutional Court rejects the motion. Choo dismissed those calculations. “This is not the time for the ruling party to calculate political gains and losses,” she wrote. “Immediate impeachment must be executed.”
Worth a look