College Football’s Most Compelling Storylines for 2026

The offseason is a time of hope for all sports fans. This year, everyone’s favorite team will right its ship, reach its potential (or beyond) and bring joy to the masses. For teams, coaches and players, the hope of fans can translate into pressure and raise the temperature in uncomfortable ways. And when things don’t go well, hope can be replaced by disappointment and impatience.

Who in college football will be most impacted by these tendencies in 2026? We’re thinking about those with expectations that things can be better, that things better gain better. There are teams looking for College Football Playoff berths, players who need to bounce back from down years and coaches who are on — or near — the hot seat.

What Team Has the Most to Prove in 2026?

Clemson faces immense pressure to rebound. After a disappointing 7-6 finish in 2025, despite a veteran roster, head coach Dabo Swinney made significant changes, bringing in Chad Morris as offensive coordinator and heavily utilizing the transfer portal, particularly on defense. The Tigers need to demonstrate that these adjustments will yield positive results and restore their status as a national contender.

USC, under Lincoln Riley, is seeking its first College Football Playoff appearance. Despite recruiting the nation’s No. 1 class, the Trojans must navigate a challenging Substantial Ten schedule, including tough matchups against Oregon, Washington, Ohio State, Indiana, and Penn State. USC needs a significant performance upgrade to meet expectations.

Wisconsin is looking to avoid a third consecutive losing season, a fate it hasn’t experienced since 1991-1992. Under Luke Fickell, the Badgers have struggled offensively and overall in Big Ten play. Wisconsin has invested in football and needs to show improvement in the expanded Big Ten.

Alabama, in Kalen DeBoer’s second season, aims to rebound from a 20-8 record and a disappointing 2025 campaign. With key players departing, including quarterback Ty Simpson, DeBoer has focused on rebuilding the offensive line and addressing the team’s struggles in running the ball and pass protection. The Crimson Tide must demonstrate progress and return to championship contention.

Alabama faces a significant challenge with an inexperienced quarterback and a revamped roster, placing considerable pressure on DeBoer to deliver results. The Tide will need to prove they can compete at a high level despite the changes.

What Coach Has the Most to Prove?

Mike Norvell (Florida State) is under intense scrutiny after a disappointing 2025 season following a 13-0 ACC championship run in 2023. Despite retaining his position, Norvell needs to demonstrate significant improvement and return the Seminoles to postseason success. Florida State has made personnel changes and is hoping for a turnaround.

Kalen DeBoer (Alabama) faces pressure to live up to the legacy of Nick Saban and deliver a team capable of competing for championships. He must develop quarterback Keelon Russell and address the defensive front seven’s reset. DeBoer’s success will be crucial for Alabama’s future.

Lane Kiffin (LSU), after a controversial departure from Ole Miss, carries high expectations at LSU, given the significant investment in his program. He needs to quickly deliver results and justify the financial commitment made by the university. LSU fans will demand immediate success.

Matt Rhule (Nebraska), despite a contract extension through 2032, needs to show tangible progress after three seasons with a 19-19 record. Nebraska must break its streak of losing seasons and become a consistent contender in the Big Ten.

Shane Beamer (South Carolina) needs to prove he can build on past successes and establish a consistent winning program. He must get more out of quarterback LaNorris Sellers and improve the team’s overall performance. South Carolina needs to demonstrate sustained success.

Which Quarterback Has the Most to Prove?

DJ Lagway (Florida) needs to live up to the hype and demonstrate consistent performance after a mixed first season. He must regain his confidence and become a reliable leader for the Gators. Lagway’s success will be critical for Florida’s future.

Sam Leavitt (LSU), a highly-touted transfer from Arizona State, faces pressure to perform immediately under Lane Kiffin. He must prove he can handle the expectations and lead the Tigers to success. Leavitt’s performance will be key for LSU’s championship aspirations.

Marcel Reed (Texas A&M) needs to build on a promising start and avoid repeating past mistakes. He must deliver consistent performances in crucial games and lead the Aggies to a breakthrough season. Reed’s ability to perform under pressure will be vital for Texas A&M.

Arch Manning (Texas), surrounded by a talented roster, is expected to lead the Longhorns to the College Football Playoff. He must manage expectations and deliver consistent performances against a challenging schedule. Manning will be under intense scrutiny as he aims to fulfill his potential.

Which Non-QB Has the Most to Prove?

Ryan Williams (Alabama) needs to regain his form after a disappointing 2025 season. He must become a reliable target for the Crimson Tide’s quarterback and contribute significantly to the offense. Williams’ performance will be crucial for Alabama’s success.

Makhi Hughes (Houston), a transfer from Tulane, needs to make an immediate impact and justify the expectations surrounding his arrival. He must become a key contributor to the Cougars’ offense and help them maintain their success. Hughes will be expected to lead the Houston rushing attack.

Dylan Stewart (South Carolina) must live up to his preseason All-American billing and become a dominant force on the defensive line. He needs to improve his sack numbers and overall impact on the game. Stewart’s performance will be vital for South Carolina’s defensive success.