International Edition
Latest News
Business

Colorado PERA Board Caps Investment Staff Bonuses After Sun Investigation

The Colorado Public Employees’ Retirement Association board voted 11-5 on Friday to replace its investment-staff bonus policy after a Colorado Sun investigation found the fund paid millions in incentives worth as much as three times base salaries while…

Colorado PERA Board Caps Investment Staff Bonuses After Sun Investigation

The Colorado Public Employees’ Retirement Association board voted 11-5 on Friday to replace its investment-staff bonus policy after a Colorado Sun investigation found the fund paid millions in incentives worth as much as three times base salaries while retiree benefits were being cut.

The new policy caps bonuses for top investment officials at 150% of salary, down from 225%, and for analysts at 50% to 100%, down from 75% to 150%. The old formula, adopted in 2018, targeted pay above 75% of a peer group that mixed public pensions with private-sector firms and endowments. The revised version aims for compensation “competitive” with top public pensions and ties private-sector benchmarks to the bottom quartile of bonus pay.

“This is a preemptive move,” said Tina Mueh, a retired schoolteacher and board member. “We are not doing this in a vacuum.”

PERA Executive Director Andrew Roth told the board that without the change, the fund would have faced bonus obligations as high as 677% of salary for some staff, pushing total incentive costs to $32 million — $8 million above the amount approved under the new caps. CalPERS, the nation’s largest public pension, caps investment bonuses at 270% of salary.

Several board members opposed the reduction. Andrew Schremp, a gubernatorial appointee who works in private equity, voted no. “I’ll be blunt: I don’t like this at all,” Schremp said. “I don’t even know why we’re having this discussion.”

Scott Simon, who also serves as chief investment officer for Colorado’s firefighter and police pension, called the decision “pennywise and pound foolish.” He said PERA’s internal management saves $100 million annually compared with outside managers and warned that the changes risk an exodus of investment staff. “The current model’s working,” Simon said. “And if we’re unique, maybe we embrace that uniqueness.”

Roth said he does not expect a mass departure and noted the new policy allows staff to return to the board for adjustments if recruitment suffers. “We are not at this point in time expecting any kind of mass exodus,” he told the board during a Thursday budget hearing.

The vote followed months of pressure from lawmakers and PERA members. Over the past two decades, the fund has cut retiree benefits and required billions more in contributions from public workers and taxpayer-funded agencies. In 2022, when PERA posted a negative return, nine investment officials still received more than $400,000 each in incentive pay.

State Sen. Chris Kolker, a Centennial Democrat, has proposed banning bonuses entirely in years the fund loses money.

The coalition Secure PERA asked the board for authority to defer or eliminate bonuses when PERA misses its 7.25% assumed rate of return. Under Roth’s plan, the board can defer bonuses for 12 months after a negative return but cannot cancel them.

Karen Wick, program manager for Secure PERA, told the board Friday that members want “strong and credible oversight.”

“When members and retirees are being asked to make sacrifices to keep PERA financially strong, they should have the confidence that the system is working just as hard on their behalf,” Wick said.

It remains unclear whether the changes will satisfy legislators. The board’s vote delivered some of what critics sought — a cap on bonuses — but not the full elimination or stricter performance triggers they have demanded.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.