Linguistic Analysis Casts Eye on Irish Identity and Poppy Culture
Author and linguist Darach Ó Séaghdha examines the complex cultural signs surrounding Irishness and the distinct divergence in remembrance traditions between Ireland and Britain. In his work, Ó Séaghdha highlights how historical fractures, particularly the 1921 introduction of the remembrance poppy by the British Legion, continue to shape contemporary perceptions across the Irish Sea.
The remembrance poppy originated in 1921 when the British Legion began selling artificial replicas of Flanders field flowers to support financially distressed veterans of the First World War. While Canada, America and France had already run similar initiatives, the symbol carried a different resonance in Ireland. Ó Séaghdha notes that the remembrance poppy from its inception included soldiers whose guns were pointed at Irish people, creating a lasting cultural divide that persists today.
Charitable Rankings and Shifting Public Perception
The cultural ubiquity of the poppy in Britain has evolved significantly since the death of the last British First World War veteran in 2012. Symbols once reserved for coats have increasingly appeared on soccer player jerseys and television workout gear. At the same time, the Royal British Legion’s standing among UK charities has shifted. In 2025, the Royal British Legion ranked 65th among UK charities, trailing organisations such as the RSPCA at 63rd, the Dogs Trust at 61st, Islamic Relief Worldwide at 40th, and the RNLI at 30th.
Public figures who decline to wear the symbol, most notably James McClean, frequently face intense public scrutiny. Meanwhile, alternative symbols like the purple poppy have emerged to commemorate patriotic animals that died in wars, though the proliferation of varied remembrance tokens occasionally draws criticism from traditionalists. Efforts since the presidency of Mary McAleese to re-examine Ireland’s relationship with the Great War have sought to address the treatment of returning soldiers, though public poppy-wearing remains uncommon in Dublin outside of specific institutions like the Freemasons Lodge on Molesworth Street.
Keep reading