In a column for TwistedSifter, Benjamin Cottrell reports that a 60-year-old father asked his daughter to lock her cat in a separate room while hosting Christmas in her small apartment, sparking a family dispute when she refused.
The daughter and her husband immediately rejected the demand. They argued that the apartment belongs to the animal just as much as it belongs to them. TwistedSifter reported that the family members scheduled to visit do not have cat allergies. They simply dislike cats.
When the pet owner stood her ground, the conversation quickly deteriorated. She said that her stepmother demanded the animal be sequestered.
“She has also been drinking and slurring her words, which always seems to be the case when I talk to them (usually at night),” the pet owner told TwistedSifter.
The disagreement highlights a sharp divide in holiday hosting etiquette. Another report by cheezburger.com said that while cat owners view their pets as family members, non-pet owners often expect concessions for their comfort. Cheezburger.com pointed out that guests who dislike animals frequently demand changes to a host’s living arrangements.
The debate quickly drew attention online.
Commenters on social media debated whether hosts must accommodate guest preferences or protect their pets from stressful isolation. TwistedSifter said that online communities generally support pet owners in such standoffs.
Critics of the pet owner argued that spending a few hours in a bedroom with food, water, and toys is hardly a severe punishment. They suggested the owner turned a simple request into a major standoff.
The holiday gathering appears unlikely to happen at the apartment. The homeowner stated she is prepared to cancel the event rather than banish her pet.
“I feel like just telling them that if I host, he’s not being put away, or you’ll have to find somewhere else to have Christmas,” the pet owner told TwistedSifter.
Family celebrations typically take place at the daughter’s sister’s home instead. The latest disagreement suggests the family will likely return to that traditional venue for the holiday season.
Keep reading