“You’re nothing but a liar, a cheat, and a thief,” Hussein Aly told Aiden Pleterski in an Ontario Superior Court courtroom.
The cross-examination of the self-styled "Crypto King" entered its second day at the kidnapping and extortion trial of Alfredo Paladino, Akil Heywood and Rakeem Henry, who are accused of abducting Pleterski in early December 2022.
Aly, representing Heywood, accused Pleterski of fabricating the kidnapping to deflect from a Ponzi scheme that took in $40 million from investors between January 2020 and August 2022 but deployed only $670,000 — 1.6 percent — into actual investments, according to accounting evidence presented at trial and reported by the Toronto Sun.
"You weren’t the ‘Crypto King.’ You were the ‘Lying King,’" Aly said, alleging Pleterski spent $13 million on lifestyle expenses including more than ten luxury vehicles while paying out $15 million to earlier investors.
Pleterski denied the characterization. "I’m not a scammer," he replied under oath, maintaining he lost millions in the crypto market crash rather than misappropriating funds. He also testified he never promoted himself as the "Crypto King" and did not pay for a Forbes profile that used the moniker.
Defence suggests kidnapping was staged
Leora Shemesh, counsel for Paladino, introduced a secret audio recording played for the jury on Friday.
This is the plan and a roadmap of how this kidnapping is going to play out,” Shemesh said to Pleterski during cross-examination. “You are directing these men how you’re going to do it and how you’re going to sell it.
Pleterski denied directing the alleged kidnappers. He testified the recording was made after he was abducted and that he lied about his former landlord, Sandeep Gupta, hiding assets to engineer an in-person meeting where he hoped to escape.

Competing accounts of injuries
Shemesh offered an alternative explanation for Pleterski’s injuries, suggesting they resulted from a fight with a man known as "Slime" — identified by the Crown as Akyeam-Pong — who is not on trial. Shemesh said "Slime" was upset because the plan to extract money from Gupta was failing and police had become involved.
"No one counted on Gupta calling 911, not even you," Shemesh told Pleterski.
Pleterski rejected the claim, reiterating he was kidnapped and beaten by his captors. Police photographed his injuries after his release, images the Crown entered as exhibits.
Crown outlines alleged timeline
The Crown alleges the kidnapping began the night of Dec. 5, 2022, when Akyeam-Pong — an acquaintance of Pleterski’s friend Clayton Soyka — lured Pleterski to a meeting at the Ritz-Carlton in Toronto. The Crown said video surveillance will show that Pleterski met Akyeam-Pong, Henry and a third person that day.
Akyeam-Pong was driving a black Dodge Ram pickup truck later used in the abduction, the Crown said. On Dec. 6, almost 24 hours after the kidnapping, and again on the morning of Dec. 7, Pleterski contacted Gupta to arrange an in-person meeting at a Tim Hortons in Scarborough. CCTV footage shows Mr. Paladino walk into the Tim Hortons and wait, said the Crown in its opening address.

All three accused have pleaded not guilty.
Pleterski’s credibility central to trial
At his trial, Pleterski, who was self-represented, did not cross-examine any of the Crown’s witnesses or present a defence.
"The only thing you’re interested in is protecting yourself. You have no respect for this court and no respect for jurors," Aly told Pleterski on Wednesday.
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice is one of the busiest trial courts in the world and the largest superior trial court in Canada. It sits in over 52 locations across eight judicial regions and holds jurisdiction over all civil proceedings in Ontario, including Divisional Court and Small Claims Court, as well as any indictable offence under the Criminal Code.
"I disagree with that," Pleterski replied.