A judge issued a temporary restraining order on Monday blocking Republican state Sen. Chris Garten from taking the oath of office or being seated in Senate District 45, the Indiana Capital Chronicle reported.
The legal action stems from ballot discrepancies tied to a malfunctioning voting machine at Jeffersonville High School during the Nov. 3 election, Axios reported. Unofficial returns show Garten leading Democratic challenger Nick Marshall by 297 votes, which represents less than 1% of the total ballots cast.
Party leaders maintained that a machine breakdown left them with no alternative recourse after the county election board rejected a recount request. Scott County Circuit Court Judge Jason Mount issued the order ahead of the legislative session’s Organization Day.
“Every person involved in this situation agrees there were significant issues with the election,” said Miguel Hampton, Karen Tallian, and Adam Dickey in a joint statement released by party chairs.
“The only disagreement is whether or not we should look into it,” the statement continued.
Court to Hear Injunction Request
The Clark County Democratic Party filed the lawsuit against Garten, the Clark County Clerk, and the Clark County Election Board, Axios reported. The complaint requests a judicial review of the election board’s refusal to hand-count ballots from the affected precinct.

The court filing also asks for a preliminary injunction to halt certification of the race. Mount scheduled a hearing on the preliminary injunction for Wednesday afternoon in Jeffersonville.
The court record indicates Mount, a Democrat, was appointed as a special judge following the recusal of a Clark County judge. Mount is the brother of Republican U.S. Rep. Erin Houchin, who previously served in the state Senate alongside Garten, according to the Indiana Capital Chronicle.
Machine Shows Ballot Discrepancies
The dispute centers on voting anomalies recorded at Jeffersonville High School, where a machine memory stick was transferred to a backup device.
Court documents state that the machine’s results tape reported 1,640 ballots cast. However, records show 474 ballots were cast before the machine replacement, only 333 voters had signed in by 11:08 a.m., and over 100 voters signed in after polls closed at 7:00 p.m., the Indiana Capital Chronicle reported.
Garten defended the integrity of the vote count in a statement issued Wednesday. Precinct records show 1,640 votes cast with 1,612 recorded, which he described as a minor discrepancy far smaller than his 297-vote margin.

“There is a significant difference between raising legitimate questions and making inflammatory accusations that undermine public confidence in our elections,” Garten said.
Next Steps in District 45
Organization Day, the ceremonial start of the legislative session, took place on Tuesday, the Indiana Capital Chronicle reported.
Garten’s office did not respond to requests for comment regarding the restraining order. Candidates face a Tuesday deadline to file recount petitions, while county party chairs have until Friday to submit requests, according to court schedules.
Keep reading