International Edition
Latest News
Business

Doctoral Thesis Reframes Railway History Through Air Pollution (France, Britain, 1820s-1960s)

A doctoral thesis reframes railway history by treating locomotive smoke as a central constraint on the development of the rail network from the 1820s to the 1960s, rather than a byproduct of progress. The study, published in Artefact…

A doctoral thesis reframes railway history by treating locomotive smoke as a central constraint on the development of the rail network from the 1820s to the 1960s, rather than a byproduct of progress.

The study, published in Artefact by historian Arthur Émile, argues that the visible smoke of steam traction was dissociated from the memory of environmental pollution by heritage narratives that celebrate the "locomotive of progress." By comparing France and Great Britain, the research shows how air contamination shaped technical choices, labor conditions, and public policy across a century and a half, according to Openedition.

Émile’s thesis, defended at the École polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL) under the direction of Jérôme Baudry and François Jarrige, draws on digitized newspapers, railway company archives, administrative and judicial records, oral histories of railway workers, and medical literature.

The comparative approach reveals that despite different relationships to coal — Britain as the "civilization of coal" and France with distinct energy inequalities — both nations followed common patterns in perceiving and framing the novel problem of mobile combustion in inhabited spaces.

Early constraints and the coke compromise

From the first public lines in the 1820s, tensions over coal smoke forced railway operators into an immediate "acclimatization strategy," the thesis finds. Companies adopted coke, a less smoky fuel, to enable an "enchantment of steam traction" that accompanied early network development.

This contradicts historiography that has often mocked or ignored early opposition to railways, the study notes, exposing the origins of a technophile rhetoric that used the promise of "smokeless" engines to discredit resistance.

The rebound effect of cheaper coal

As main networks were completed, operators increasingly switched to cheaper, smokier bituminous coal to achieve economies of scale, creating new tensions with passengers and neighbors. The thesis identifies a rebound effect: improvements in firebox combustion efficiency encouraged the use of difficult, low-grade coals. Engineers’ promises of "smokeless" devices functioned as both "magical thinking" and a decoy to avoid constraining industrial development, the study argues, echoing analyses of fixed industrial furnaces.

Workers as the first line of defense

Railway companies relied primarily on engine drivers and firemen to compensate for insufficient pollution-control technology, even as those workers were the first exposed to intensifying smoke in cabins, depots, and tunnels.

By examining energy transitions from the viewpoint of workers responsible for producing power and limiting its "overflow," the thesis contributes to an environmental history of labor worlds. The drivers, sharing the nickname "gueules noires" (black faces) with coal miners in France, developed a singular relationship to fuel that the study explores through edited memoirs and oral-history collections.

The "smoke locomotive" image and urban alternatives

By the late 19th century, the persistent gap between the promised "smokeless locomotive" and the reality of the "smoke locomotive" cemented an association between the machine and air contamination.

This image was reinforced by the urban experience of electric traction, which challenged steam’s place in the imagination of modernity and contributed to its "disenchantment." The thesis deconstructs the commonplace notion that the public simply habituated to nuisance, showing instead that social demand for electrification driven by smoke abatement grew throughout the 20th century alongside rising traffic and urban co-development.

From local nuisance to public health problem

The research identifies perception biases — familiarity, dispersion, and the seemingly mobile nature of railway smoke — that led to underestimating its significance and delayed its reframing from a local nuisance to a national public health issue.

These biases mirrored those affecting automotive and domestic emissions. The comparative lens shows Britain presented more favorable conditions for placing railway pollution on the political agenda, notably because the 1952 Great Smog of London acted as a revelatory catastrophe.

Exit from steam and the green rebranding

In a context of growing competition from road transport, the gradual awareness by railway actors and decision-makers of the direct and indirect costs of air pollution participated in the post-World War II choice to exit steam for an oil-electric mix, the thesis concludes.

Nationalized railways then shed a stigma of dirtiness to reinvent the train as a clean, responsible transport mode — the foundation of its current ecological image. The study examines the ambiguities of this technical disappearance, including the popular attachment to the steam locomotive that paradoxically fueled the dissociation between the machine and its smoke.

Founded as a private school in 1853, the institution became a federal institute in 1969, separating from the University of Lausanne to form the École polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne under direct control of the Swiss Federal Council. As of 2025, it enrolls 14,072 students from over 130 countries, a sharp rise from the 1,400 students and 55 faculty members recorded at its federal founding.

As anniversary celebrations reactivate a fixed imaginary of the railway, the thesis argues for restoring a plural memory of "ferroviarisation" that integrates its social and environmental costs. The erasure of industrialization’s negative dimensions, the study warns, limits understanding of the current environmental crisis — in the writing of history as in the activity of heritage and museum actors.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.