International Edition
Latest News
Business

How Unemployment Insurance Impacted Labor Force Participation and Earnings for Women and Men During the Great Recession

Unemployment insurance kept more women attached to the labor force during the Great Recession, but the benefits failed to lift their earnings, according to a study published in MDPI's Social Sciences journal analyzing the 2008 Survey of Income…

How Unemployment Insurance Impacted Labor Force Participation and Earnings for Women and Men During the Great Recession

Unemployment insurance kept more women attached to the labor force during the Great Recession, but the benefits failed to lift their earnings, according to a study published in MDPI’s Social Sciences journal analyzing the 2008 Survey of Income and Program Participation panel.

Researchers tracked unemployed workers with children over three years using a feminist social provisioning framework. They found that UI receipt reduced labor-force withdrawal for caregiving reasons, particularly among women. By months 25 to 36, women who received benefits showed increases in employment and work hours from their pre-separation baseline. Men showed decreases.

“UI receipt was associated with lower labor force withdrawal, particularly among women and for caregiving-related reasons,” the authors wrote.

The findings contradict traditional job-matching theory, which predicts that longer job searches supported by benefits should yield better matches and higher wages. Instead, women’s employment gains did not raise earnings, which remained lower for both sexes throughout the follow-up period.

The analysis examined two state-level provisions designed to expand eligibility for family reasons. The Compelling Family Reasons provision was associated with larger increases in mid-period caregiving-related withdrawal and larger decreases in late-period employment and hours among women, though joint tests for outcomes were not significant after multiple-testing correction.

The Part-Time provision showed less consistent patterns, with some negative associations for women’s hours and earnings in certain periods that also did not survive correction.

Men’s negative long-term estimates may reflect the concentration of UI recipients in construction and production sectors hit hardest by the Great Recession. Peterson (2012) characterized the downturn as a “mancession” followed by a “mancovery.” The authors caution that findings from the 2008 panel may not extend to the COVID-19 “shecession,” which disproportionately affected women’s employment and caregiving.

The study notes several limitations: the three-year SIPP window precludes longer-term assessment; UI benefit receipt is significantly underreported in survey data; selection into UI receipt based on unobserved characteristics limits causal interpretation; and state implementation of CFR and PT provisions varied qualitatively, potentially attenuating observed effects.

About the author: Business Desk

Business Desk at Archynewsy.