Four African American patients underwent repeat colonoscopy within 12 months of a prior exam, and the medical record often did not say why, a case series published in Cureus found.
The report reviewed five patients who had a repeat colonoscopy within one year at a single academic endoscopy unit between 2010 and 2021. Four were African American and older than 50; the fifth was excluded to match the series focus. The cases were identified by the clinical team, not a systematic search, so the total number of eligible patients and procedures during that period is not known, the authors wrote.
Two of the four qualifying index-repeat pairs — Case 2 at six months and Case 3 at seven months — followed exams with documented suboptimal preparation or poor visualization. Those repeats were classified as supported by the U.S. Multi-Society Task Force (USMSTF) guidance in effect at the time, the study said.
The other two qualifying pairs — Case 1 at nine months during post-cancer surveillance and Case 4 with four repeats within 12 months after an index exam showing two adenomas with high-grade dysplasia — were classified as indeterminate. The records did not link preparation quality, resection completeness, or procedural rationale to the specific examinations, the authors wrote. Advanced histology alone did not justify an interval shorter than 12 months under any applicable guideline, they added.
The series assessed each index-repeat pair against the guideline in effect when the preceding exam was performed: the 2006 USMSTF guidance for procedures before September 2012, the 2012 guidance from September 2012 to February 2020, and the 2020 guidance thereafter. Post-cancer surveillance was assessed against 2006 and 2016 post-resection guidance. Repeat exams after inadequate preparation were assessed against 2014 USMSTF bowel-preparation recommendations, applied retrospectively to Cases 2 and 3. The 2020 guidance was used only as a secondary contemporary comparison.
A pair was classified as supported when the record documented an indication the applicable guidance recognizes for repeat colonoscopy within 12 months — inadequate preparation, piecemeal or incomplete resection, more than 10 adenomas under the 2020 guidance, a scheduled post-cancer exam, or a documented diagnostic indication. It was classified as not clearly supported when documentation was adequate and no such indication existed. It was indeterminate when documentation did not allow either determination.
Higher adenoma detection rates have been associated with lower risks of interval colorectal cancer and CRC death. Inadequate bowel preparation increases adenoma miss rates, and fair or worse preparation has been associated with a higher risk of post-colonoscopy CRC death.
African American patients bear a disproportionate burden of colorectal cancer.
The observations cannot estimate the frequency of low-value colonoscopy or address racial differences in surveillance practice, the authors wrote. The Institutional Review Board approved the retrospective review and waived the requirement for individual informed consent. The case series was prepared with reference to the CARE reporting guidelines.