Texas Comptroller Don Huffines proposed rule changes on Nov. 17 and Nov. 18 that would eliminate state sales taxes on video streaming, cloud computing, internet hosting and artificial intelligence services, arguing his office has improperly extended decades-old tax laws to technologies the legislature never intended to tax.
The two proposals, scheduled for publication in the Texas Register on Nov. 20 with comments due Dec. 20, would narrow the definition of taxable data processing to services that process customer-supplied data and return it in an organized format. They would also remove internet-delivered video from the definition of taxable cable television service under Tax Code § 151.0033 and clarify it is not a taxable amusement service. “If the Legislature wants to tax streaming, they can pass a law and own it,” Huffines said in the Nov. 17 announcement. “In 2014, bureaucrats decided a law written in 1984 for cable boxes somehow covered streaming. Nobody voted on that. No law was passed.” The Texas Dispatch reported that Huffines traced the streaming tax to a 2014 administrative interpretation of the 1984 cable statute. The proposed amendments to 34 Tex. Admin. Code § 3.313 would reverse that interpretation, though programming delivered over the internet as part of a cable provider’s own cable system would remain taxable. The second proposal targets Rule 3.308 and Tax Code § 151.0035, which the comptroller’s office has long interpreted to cover any computerized storage or manipulation of data. The Texas Dispatch reported the amendments would define taxable data processing narrowly — word processing, data entry, payroll and similar services performed on a customer’s own information — while expressly excluding cloud computing, AI, quantum computing and internet hosting. “The Legislature taxed data processing in 1987,” Huffines said in the Nov. 18 release. “It did not tax the internet. It did not tax the cloud. It did not tax artificial intelligence.”
The Dispatch, citing fiscal notes published in the Nov. 20 Texas Register, said the three rule changes — streaming, hosted technology and a separate compressor exemption for oil and gas — would cost the state general revenue fund about $2.42 billion in fiscal 2027 and $4.9 billion annually by 2032. Cities, counties and transit authorities would lose an additional $644 million in the first year. The hosted-technology change alone accounts for $1.95 billion of the 2027 state loss, rising to $4.29 billion in 2032, with local losses growing from $507 million to $1.12 billion over the same period. The streaming proposal carries a $290 million state cost in 2027, growing to $376 million in 2032, plus $84 million in first-year local losses. A related software-allocation change would reduce revenue further by an amount the agency said “cannot be estimated.”
Comptroller-elect Sarah Eckhardt, who takes office Jan. 1, 2027, sent Huffines a letter on Nov. 9 requesting he cease pursuing rule changes initiated since Aug. 1 as part of an orderly transition. Huffines rejected the request in a Nov. 16 letter, calling it “a demand to kill the Taxpayer First Project and every reform in it.”
The Texas Dispatch noted the proposals build on earlier Huffines actions, including reversing the taxation of marketplace commissions and proposing an exemption for electronic health record systems. Whether the rules are finalized before Eckhardt takes office — and whether they survive her administration — remains unresolved. The public comment period closes Dec. 20. The agency can adopt the rules after that date.
More on Texas Register
Comptroller Don Huffines announced new rules confirming that cloud computing, internet hosting and AI are not taxable data processing services. He said, “Texas will be the home of the technologies of the future, not the state that taxes them to death.” pic.twitter.com/n4VPCrnxuN
Worth a look
- Augsburger Panther Beat Nürnberg Ice Tigers 5-4 in Shootout After Disallowed OT Winner
- Romania’s Niculescu Government Names New Bucharest Prefect, Nine Subprefects
- Next Halts Baby Sleep Bag Sales After Mother Raises Alarm (news-usa.today)
- Grand Theft Auto VI Album: 34 Tracks Available Now on Streaming and Vinyl (archyworldys.com)