East Lansing Limits Human Rights Commission Investigation Powers Following Legal Advice
East Lansing City Council amended the ordinance governing the Human Rights Commission to strip the body of its ability to review complaints against city employees and cases filed with another investigatory body, eastlansinginfo.news reported. The changes followed months of tension between volunteer commissioners and city attorneys regarding legal risk, pending litigation, and the scope of municipal oversight.
The restructuring arrives in the wake of a 2025 incident where an East Lansing Police Department officer pepper-sprayed Lonnie Smith and Mason Woods downtown. The ELPD issued a press release naming both men and stating they faced fighting charges, a step noted as highly unusual for common misdemeanors. Video footage later showed Smith intervened to break up an altercation before both men were sprayed.
Smith and Woods subsequently filed lawsuits against the city in November, prompting city officials to decline public comment to protect insurance coverage.
Legal Advice Triggers Commission Clashes Over Policy Authority
City attorneys defended the ordinance changes by arguing that internal personnel matters must be handled by the city manager under the city charter. However, commissioners questioned why the restrictions also barred concurrent investigations with outside bodies such as the MDCR.
Commissioner Jonathan Forman, who served on a city charter review committee in 2024 and 2025, stated that former City Attorney Tony Chubb never raised conflicts between the charter and commission powers. Forman argued that shifting investigation rules created perverse incentives for respondents to run out local deadlines.
Mayor Pro Tem Chuck Grigsby attended the meeting as the council liaison and defended the adjustments as a policy determination defining whether the commission operates with an investigatory or advisory dynamic. Commissioners countered that elected representatives should dictate policy rather than deferring entirely to legal counsel behind closed doors.
Police Oversight Commission Confronts Use of Force Spike
The East Lansing Independent Police Oversight Commission reviewed a 2025 use of force report authored by Adrian College sociology and criminal justice professor Cedrick Heraux. The report documented a more than 50% spike in use-of-force incidents, with the majority occurring in downtown East Lansing.
ELIPOC Chair Ernest Conerly proposed inviting community stakeholders, including Brown and primary city attorney Carlito Young, to an open meeting to discuss solutions. Young immediately advised against a broad public discussion, citing potential legal liabilities.
You know where my advice is going to lead in a public setting about issues that can affect the city,
Young told the commission.
Why East Lansing Changed Its Human Rights Commission Ordinance?
Why did East Lansing change the Human Rights Commission ordinance?
The City Council amended the ordinance to comply with city charter rules requiring internal handling of personnel matters and to address legal liability concerns raised by city attorneys regarding active litigation.
Who currently provides legal services for the city of East Lansing?
The city switched to Rosati, Schultz, Joppich and Amtsbuechler for most legal services, with Carlito Young serving as the primary city attorney for the last several months.
Related reading