Three transmission towers on South Australia’s Eyre Peninsula collapsed during a severe storm on Thursday, cutting power to the region despite a $300 million network upgrade completed just two years ago.
The towers fell around 2:30 p.m. on a 270-kilometre high-voltage line between Port Lincoln and Cultana, near the rural locality of Wharminda, ElectraNet executive Alex Trento told a state government press conference on Friday. The line, known as the Eyre Peninsula Link, opened in March 2023 after the construction of 500 new towers and upgrades to five substations, ABC News reported.
Premier says cost falls to private operator
Premier Peter Malinauskas declined to commit state funding for repairs, emphasizing that ElectraNet operates as a private, for-profit monopoly.
In some pleasing news, power is being progressively restored to large parts of Eyre Peninsula and the West Coast, after storms brought down major transmission towers yesterday. Crews from Electranet have successfully completed a temporary reconfiguration of their network at…
“This is a private company and a private operator that runs a healthy profit for their shareholders,” Mr Malinauskas said. “This is not a question for us. That’s a question for them.”
Energy Minister Tom Koutsantonis echoed that stance earlier Friday, telling 891 ABC Adelaide there would be “a lot of questions” about how the upgrades — paid for through consumer power bills — had failed.
Wind speeds likely exceeded design limits
ElectraNet holds a “strong belief” that wind speeds at the site exceeded 172 km/h, which is above the threshold the towers were engineered to withstand under current Australian standards. Those standards were tightened in 2016 following the statewide blackout that year.
Mr Trento said the localized nature of the damage suggested the towers were “designed and constructed effectively,” though he did not rule out a structural fault. He estimated wind speeds may have reached 215 km/h, but said the company must wait for all data before determining if engineering standards require further revision.
“Unfortunately, you can never guarantee that the transmission network will not be subject to these extreme weather events.”
Mr Trento
Mr Trento said.
Redundancy rejected over cost
The Australian Energy Regulator (AER) approved $280 million for the Eyre Peninsula Link in September 2020. Mr Trento said a secondary circuit — which could have provided redundancy during Thursday’s outage — was evaluated during planning but would have doubled the project cost to roughly $600 million.
Today I gave an update on efforts to restore power across Eyre Peninsula after last night’s storms. pic.twitter.com/zMDNEoKsgB
Mr Trento said the cost would have eventually been passed to consumers. “It all comes down to cost,” he said. “We can make things as big as we want to, and it will be like a Colosseum, and it will stand 2,000 years. But that’s not efficient or prudent spending and will never get approved by the AER.”
He conceded repair costs would ultimately be recovered through consumer energy bills, though at a fraction of the cost of a duplicate line.
Residents question value of upgrade
Port Lincoln business owner Jan Regan, who closed her hearing care clinic Thursday after losing computer access and repair capabilities, questioned the investment.
“Was it money well spent? Probably not, if you spend that much and it fails.”
she said. “We’re not a third-world country. I don’t quite know what’s happening, but it needs to be looked at.”
ElectraNet operates 5,591 kilometres of high-voltage transmission lines across South Australia, where wind and solar regularly meet the state’s entire electricity demand. The company is owned by Australian Utilities Pty Ltd (53.44%) and State Grid Corporation of China (46.56%).
Its 2026 planning report projects peak demand could more than double to over 6.5 gigawatts in 15 years, driven by data centres, defence industry growth and the Whyalla steelworks, and outlines a project pipeline valued around A$3.94 billion.
The Australian reported the storm was described by the Premier as a “one-in-2000-year weather event” and warned the state is “not out of the woods yet.”