“La banque reste responsable de la sécurisation de l’envoi de ses moyens de paiement,” the Valenciennes judicial tribunal wrote in a February 10 judgment that placed liability for intercepted replacement cards squarely on the issuing bank.
The ruling, citing Article L. 133-15 of the Monetary and Financial Code, held that a customer whose replacement card was diverted after a fraudulent change-of-address request never had custody of the security device.
The bank was ordered to reimburse the full amount of fraudulent withdrawals, plus penalty interest at the legal rate plus ten points from August 16, 2021, and the cost of a revolving credit the client took out to cover the resulting overdraft.
Delivery risk stays with the bank
The decision highlights a legal framework that allocates delivery risk to payment-service providers until the card and its PIN are physically handed to the authorized user. Article L. 133-15 IV states the provider “bears the risk linked to the sending to the payer of a payment instrument or of any personalized security credentials.”
Searches for “carte de paiement” surged on Google in France on November 19, 2026, with autocomplete suggestions including “carte bancaire périmée que faire” and “carte bancaire expirée que faire,” according to kohenavocats.com.
Replacement window: bank assumes delivery risk
Article L. 133-15 permits unsolicited dispatch only when replacing an expiring or blocked instrument. Any other unsolicited card should trigger an immediate call to the bank using a number from the contract or the secure client area — never from a message.
If the new card does not arrive, the customer must notify the bank “without delay” under Article L. 133-17 so the instrument can be blocked. The bank must provide free, 24/7 means to report the loss and, on request, proof that the notification was made. Once informed, it must prevent any further use of the card.
Article L. 133-19 sets a €50 deductible for unauthorized transactions made before the bank is notified, but it exempts the payer entirely when the loss or theft “could not be detected by the payer before the payment” or when the instrument was diverted without the payer’s knowledge. The Valenciennes tribunal applied this exemption, finding the client could not be negligent for a card he never received.
Reimbursement must occur “immediately” and no later than the end of the first business day after the bank learns of the unauthorized operation, per Article L. 133-18.
Penalty interest accrues at the legal rate plus five points, rising to plus ten points after seven days and plus fifteen points after thirty days. The Valenciennes court applied the ten-point surcharge from August 16, 2021, after the client alerted the bank on July 15, 2021, according to Kohenavocats.
After a valid opposition, the bank may charge only “the replacement costs directly attributable to that payment instrument” under Article L. 133-26 IV. Administrative or dispute-handling fees beyond the physical card’s production and mailing costs are not permitted.
Fraud scenarios: bank must prove authentication, not just log entries
When a customer disputes the resulting transactions, the burden of proof rests on the bank.
Article L. 133-23 requires the provider to prove the operation was authenticated, properly recorded and accounted for, and not affected by a technical deficiency. “The use of the payment instrument as recorded by the payment service provider does not necessarily suffice to prove that the operation was authorized by the payer,” the article says.
The Court of Cassation reinforced this principle in a July 1, 2026 ruling (No. 25-13.134), published in the Bulletin. It overturned an appellate decision that had presumed consent from the mere use of the customer’s identifier, access code and hardware token. The high court held the lower court “reversed the burden of proof” by deducing authorization solely from the contractual authentication method.
The Paris Court of Appeal applied the same logic on June 18, 2026 (Pôle 4, Chambre 9-A, RG No. 25/06701). A cardholder who mistakenly ordered a renewal instead of blocking a stolen card saw 120 payments totaling €8,734.15 executed in two days. The bank produced only extracts from its monetics management software, without detailed transaction logs or technical authentication data.
The court ruled that “proof of authentication of a payment operation cannot result from the mere existence of an authorization number or its recording in the provider’s information systems” and ordered full reimbursement without even examining possible gross negligence.
Gross negligence remains a statutory bar to reimbursement under Article L. 133-19 IV. The Paris judicial tribunal found it on September 9, 2026 (RG No. 24/07009) against a client who, after calling a number received by SMS, activated an authentication device on a new phone and handed both her old card and a newly received replacement to a fake courier.
The court noted she “should have been alerted by the request to hand over a bank card, which is not necessary to make an opposition.” No bank needs physical possession of a card to block it.
That same judgment, however, barred the bank from clawing back a provisional reimbursement. After initially refunding the withdrawals, the bank debited €9,910 two weeks later citing gross negligence.
The tribunal held Articles L. 133-18 and L. 133-19 “do not authorize a reimbursement by the bank only on a provisional basis, pending a more precise analysis.” Absent a contractual clause allowing it, the clawback was an unauthorized debit that the bank had to restore.
The Court of Cassation confirmed on March 27, 2024 (No. 22-21.200) that the regime for unauthorized operations (Articles L. 133-18 to L. 133-24) is exclusive. In a January 15, 2025 ruling (No. 23-13.579), it held that when the payer commits gross negligence, the payer bears all losses and the bank’s liability “could not be sought on the basis of its vigilance and monitoring obligations.”
An effective claim therefore rests on the unauthorized nature of the operation, timely notification under Article L. 133-24, and the bank’s burden of proof.
After expiration: subscriptions survive the card
A card’s expiry does not terminate the underlying contracts — streaming services, gym memberships, online subscriptions — that generate recurring payments. Article L. 133-3 defines a payment operation as a transfer of funds “independently of any underlying obligation between the payer and the beneficiary.”
To stop the debits, the customer must act on two fronts. Keep that confirmation.
Limits apply. Once a payment order has been transmitted to the beneficiary or consent given for a specific operation, revocation is barred under Article L. 133-8.
For SEPA direct debits, the payer may revoke the mandate no later than the end of the business day preceding the agreed debit date. Banks may not charge for revoking a SEPA mandate under Article L. 133-26 III, except in the specific case of Article L. 133-8 IV.
For variable-amount authorizations where the exact sum was not known in advance — hotel pre-authorizations, rental deposits — Article L. 133-25 allows reimbursement if the debited amount exceeds what the payer could reasonably expect. The request must be made within eight weeks of the debit. The bank then has ten business days to reimburse or justify its refusal and inform the customer of mediation rights.
Contestation deadlines: thirteen months, but “without delay” matters
Article L. 133-24 requires the user to report an unauthorized or poorly executed operation “without delay and at the latest within thirteen months of the debit date, under penalty of forfeiture.” For consumers, this deadline cannot be shortened by contract.
In the Valenciennes case, the bank argued the client was time-barred because he sued nearly three years after the fraudulent withdrawals. The tribunal rejected the argument, noting the client had contacted the bank on July 15, 2021 — the day he discovered the withdrawals and made opposition — satisfying Article L. 133-24.
Court rejects bank's unilateral contract changes
A bank’s blanket right to refuse renewal or block a card at any time without notice was deemed an abusive clause by the Court of Cassation on May 28, 2009 (No. 08-15.802), acting on a consumer association’s action. The court upheld an appellate decision striking down a clause that “reserves to the professional the right to unilaterally modify, without notice, the conditions of use of the card.”
Article L. 312-1-1 IV requires any proposed change to be communicated on paper or another durable medium at least two months before the planned effective date. A customer who refuses the modification may terminate the agreement without charge before it takes effect.
Article L. 312-1-1 V mandates a minimum two-month notice for bank-initiated termination of an indefinite-term agreement; the customer may terminate at any time with a contractual notice not exceeding thirty days. Identical rules appear in Article L. 314-13 for payment-service framework contracts.
Customers left without any payment instrument can invoke the “right to an account” under Article L. 312-1. Any person domiciled in France, without a deposit account and refused by a bank, may ask the Banque de France to designate an institution.
That institution must provide basic banking services, including “a payment card whose each use is authorized by the credit institution that issued it,” enabling online payments and euro-area cash withdrawals, per Article D. 312-5-1. The designated bank may terminate only in limited cases listed in Article L. 312-1 IV, by motivated letter with at least two months’ notice, barring suspected illegal use or false information.
Persistent disputes — over reimbursement refusal, non-renewal or contested fees — must first go to the banking mediator. Article L. 316-1 guarantees every consumer free access to mediation for disputes with a credit or payment institution. For unauthorized operations, however, the notification to the bank under Article L. 133-24 conditions the reimbursement under Article L. 133-18 and must precede any mediation request.
Practical checklist
- Card not received: Notify the bank immediately via a traceable channel; demand written confirmation of the opposition with date and time.
- Fraudulent debits on undelivered card: The bank bears the burden of proving authentication; simple log extracts are insufficient per the Paris Court of Appeal (June 18, 2026).
- Fake courier or advisor: No bank needs the physical card to block it. Handing it over constitutes gross negligence (Paris tribunal, September 9, 2026).
- Provisional reimbursement clawed back: Not permitted without a contractual clause (Paris tribunal, September 9, 2026).
Worth a look